Logosphere Bible Institute
--

Lesson 4 · 26 min

The Great Commission

Matthew 28 is the most quoted mission text in the world, and it is often quoted badly. This lesson reads the commission closely: the authority it rests on, the one command at its centre, what 'make disciples' meant to people who had walked with Jesus, and the promise that closes it. It sets the commission beside its other forms in Luke, John and Acts, weighs the argument over modelling our mission on Jesus' own, follows William Carey's case in 1792 that the commission still binds, and hears those who argue that mission rests on something deeper than a command. Your fourth page asks how your church actually makes disciples.

Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey all that I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, even to the end of the age.

Matthew 28:19-20 · BSB

Before you read

Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.

  1. Observe

    Read Matthew 28:16-20. Write down where the scene takes place, who is present, what they do when they see Jesus, and what he says first before he gives any instruction. Then list every action word in verses 19 and 20.

  2. Notice

    Matthew 28:17 says that when the disciples saw the risen Jesus, they worshiped him, 'but some doubted'. Notice what Jesus does next in verse 18. Then compare Matthew 14:31, where the same Greek verb for doubt appears. What does this tell you about the people Jesus commissioned?

  3. Hear it then

    Read Matthew 4:15-16, Matthew 10:5-6 and Matthew 28:16-19 in order. Where do the beginning and the end of Jesus' ministry take place in Matthew's Gospel, how does Matthew describe that region, and what has changed between chapter 10 and chapter 28?

  4. Weigh the words

    Using Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, look up the Greek verb translated 'make disciples' in Matthew 28:19. Find every other place in the New Testament where that verb is used: try Matthew 13:52, Matthew 27:57 and Acts 14:21. Then look up the noun for 'disciple' in Matthew 10:24-25. What does the word family describe?

  5. Show the evidence

    Matthew 28 is one form of the commission. Read Luke 24:46-49, John 20:21-23 and Acts 1:8, and Mark 16:15 with any note your Bible prints there. For each, write down who sends, what the disciples are to do, where, and with what help. What do the accounts share, and what does each one add?

  6. Why it matters

    Think of the last person who became a Christian through your church. What happened to them in the six months after they believed? Write down, without any names, what your church did to help them become a disciple, and what it did not do.

1. On a mountain in Galilee

Read the commission in its setting, not as a slogan on a banner. After the resurrection the angel and then Jesus himself tell the women to send the disciples to Galilee (Matthew 28:7, 28:10), as Jesus had promised before his death (26:32). 'Meanwhile, the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to the mountain Jesus had designated' (28:16). There are eleven, not twelve. Judas is gone. The group Jesus sends to the nations is already marked by failure; all of them had fled at his arrest, and Peter had denied him three times.

Then comes a sentence that preachers often skip: 'When they saw Him, they worshiped Him, but some doubted' (28:17). The verb for doubt, distazo, is used in only one other place in the New Testament, Matthew 14:31, where Peter starts to sink on the water and Jesus asks him why he doubted. It suggests hesitation, being of two minds, rather than flat unbelief. Matthew does not hide it. And Jesus does not dismiss the hesitant ones or wait for them to become certain. 'Then Jesus came to them' (28:18). The great commission was given to a small group of worshippers, some of whom were unsure. That should encourage any church that feels too small, too weak or too uncertain to be sent anywhere.

Before Jesus gives any instruction, he speaks of his authority: 'All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to Me' (28:18). The words echo Daniel 7:14, where one like a son of man is given dominion, glory and kingship, 'that the people of every nation and language should serve Him.' On another mountain, at the start of the Gospel, the devil had shown Jesus all the kingdoms of the world and offered them to him for worship (4:8-9). Jesus refused. Now, after the cross, all authority is given to him by the Father. The mission to the nations rests on this. The disciples do not go because they are strong, or because their culture is superior, or because the nations need what they have. They go because the one who sends them already has authority over every nation they will enter.

That foundation has a sharp edge for the history this track will tell. When Christians have carried the gospel with the authority of an empire behind them, they have often confused the two, and the nations they reached have had reason to confuse them too. Matthew 28:18 makes clear whose authority the mission rests on, and it is not the missionary's. A messenger sent by the one who has all authority has no need to borrow any from the soldiers or traders of his own nation, and every reason not to.

2. One command: make disciples

Most English translations, including the BSB, give verse 19 as two commands: 'go and make disciples.' In Greek there is only one imperative verb in the commission, matheteusate, make disciples. The word translated go, poreuthentes, is a participle, as are baptizing and teaching. This grammatical fact has been used in two opposite ways, and you should know both so that you can avoid the errors in each.

Some preachers have said that because go is a participle, it means only 'as you go', so the commission is about making disciples wherever you happen to be, and is not really a command to go anywhere. Greek grammarians have generally answered that this reads too much into the form. When a participle of this kind comes before a main imperative verb and describes an action that has to happen first, it normally shares the force of the command. Daniel Wallace, in his Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (1996), calls this an attendant circumstance participle and argues that it has imperatival force in Matthew 28:19. Matthew uses the same construction elsewhere, as in 28:7, where the angel tells the women to go quickly and tell the disciples; nobody reads that as 'as you happen to be going'. So go is a real part of the command. But the grammar also shows where the weight falls. The goal is not going; the goal is disciples. A church can send many people and make few disciples. The commission measures mission by its fruit, not by its travel.

What is a disciple? The noun mathetes means a learner or apprentice, someone who attaches himself to a teacher to learn not only what he knows but how he lives. Jesus says, 'A disciple is not above his teacher, nor a servant above his master. It is enough for a disciple to be like his teacher' (10:24-25). Discipleship in the Gospels involves being called, 'Come, follow Me' (4:19), being with Jesus, learning from him, 'Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me' (11:29), and following him at cost, 'whoever does not carry his cross and follow Me cannot be My disciple' (Luke 14:27). The verb matheteuo, to make a disciple, is rare. It appears only four times in the New Testament, at Matthew 13:52, 27:57, 28:19 and Acts 14:21. In Acts 14:21-22, Paul and Barnabas 'preached the gospel to that city and made many disciples', and then went back to strengthen the souls of the disciples and encourage them to continue in the faith, and appointed elders for them (14:23). Making disciples in Acts was not a single event. It was the start of a life.

The two participles that follow describe what disciple-making includes. Baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit is the public act by which a person is joined to Christ and to his people. It is done in one name, the name of the triune God. Very early Christian practice preserved this. The Didache, a short manual of church order usually dated to the late first or early second century, instructs in its seventh chapter that baptism be done in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Christians differ about who should be baptised, infants or believers only, and how, by immersion or pouring, and the commission does not settle those debates. But it does make baptism part of mission. A disciple belongs to a community.

The second participle is the one churches most often neglect: 'teaching them to obey all that I have commanded you' (28:20). Notice it does not say teaching them all that I have commanded, as though the goal were knowledge. It says teaching them to obey. And it says all. Matthew's Gospel is built around five long blocks of Jesus' teaching, the Sermon on the Mount in chapters 5 to 7, the mission discourse in chapter 10, the parables in chapter 13, the teaching on community in chapter 18, and the teaching on the end in chapters 24 and 25. Many readers think 'all that I have commanded you' points back to these. A church that leads people to faith and then leaves them without patient teaching in obedience has done half of what the commission asks. So has a church that teaches doctrine for years without asking anyone to change how they live. Jesus said that the wise man is the one who 'hears these words of Mine and acts on them' (7:24).

Finally, 'all nations', panta ta ethne. Scholars have debated whether in Matthew 28:19 the phrase means the Gentiles, the non-Jewish peoples, as distinct from Israel, or all peoples including Israel. Douglas Hare and Daniel Harrington argued for the first in an article of 1975. They noted that ethne in Matthew usually means the Gentiles, as in 10:5 and 20:19, and read sayings such as 21:43, where the kingdom is taken away and given to a people producing its fruit, as signs that Matthew's church had turned from the mission to Israel. John Meier answered in 1977 that the full phrase panta ta ethne in Matthew 24:9, 24:14 and 25:32 reads most naturally as all humanity, and that nothing in 28:19 shuts Israel out. Many interpreters now take Meier's wider view, that the risen Jesus sends his disciples to every people, Jews included, though the narrower reading still has able defenders, and the question bears on how Matthew saw the relation between the church and Israel. A different debate, about whether ethne should be read as distinct ethnic and language groups rather than as countries, belongs to module 4. For now, notice that the commission reaches as far as Genesis 12:3, to all the families of the earth.

3. The commission in four Gospels and Acts

The phrase 'the Great Commission' is a later label, not a biblical one, and it usually means Matthew 28. But Matthew, Luke, John and the book of Acts each include a sending by the risen Jesus, Mark's longer ending has one too, and each brings out something the others do not. A church that knows only Matthew's form may miss half of what Jesus said.

Mark's case needs care. Mark 16:15 reads, 'Go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature.' But the passage in which it stands, Mark 16:9-20, is absent from the two oldest complete Greek manuscripts of the New Testament, Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus, both from the fourth century, and it differs in style from the rest of Mark. Most scholars conclude that it was added to the Gospel later, and many modern translations print it with a note. Some scholars defend it, and it was accepted very early in the church's life; Irenaeus quotes from it in the second century. The honest course is to preach the truth it states from texts whose place is not in doubt. Mark's undisputed text has its own commission saying: 'And the gospel must first be proclaimed to all the nations' (13:10).

Luke's form comes on the evening of the resurrection. Jesus opens their minds to understand the Scriptures (24:45) and says: 'This is what is written: The Christ will suffer and rise from the dead on the third day, and in His name repentance and forgiveness of sins will be proclaimed to all nations, beginning in Jerusalem. You are witnesses of these things. And behold, I am sending the promise of My Father upon you. But remain in the city until you have been clothed with power from on high' (24:46-49). Luke's emphases are the scriptures fulfilled, the message of repentance and forgiveness, the role of witnesses, and the need to wait for the Spirit's power. The next lesson takes up Luke's second volume, where the same commission begins Acts.

John's form comes behind locked doors, 'for fear of the Jews' (John 20:19). Jesus shows them his wounds, and says: 'Peace be with you. As the Father has sent Me, so also I am sending you' (20:21). Then he breathes on them and says, 'Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive anyone his sins, they are forgiven; if you withhold forgiveness from anyone, it is withheld' (20:22-23). John's emphasis is the pattern of the sending: the disciples are sent as Jesus was sent. The verb send runs through John's Gospel; Jesus calls the Father 'Him who sent Me' again and again, and in his prayer he says, 'As You sent Me into the world, I have also sent them into the world' (17:18). In John, the church's mission is the continuation of the Son's mission, carried by the Spirit.

Acts 1:8 gives the last form, just before Jesus is taken up: 'you will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes upon you, and you will be My witnesses in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.' Put the five together and the shape is clear. The risen Jesus, who has all authority, sends his disciples to all nations, with a message of repentance and forgiveness in his name, to make disciples who are baptised and taught to obey, as witnesses empowered by the Spirit, on the pattern of his own sending, with the promise of his presence until the end of the age. No one text says all of that. Together they do.

4. As the Father sent me: a model or a mission of its own?

John 20:21 has produced one of the most important debates in modern mission, and it bears directly on what your church does. In Christian Mission in the Modern World (1975), the English pastor and theologian John Stott argued that John's form of the commission is in some ways the most crucial, because it makes Jesus' own mission the model for ours. Stott explained that he had once held that the commission was exclusively about preaching, converting and teaching; he said so openly, and said he had changed his mind. If Jesus was sent into the world to serve, to identify with people, to preach, to heal and to give his life, then the church is sent into the world in the same way. Our mission, Stott argued, must therefore include both evangelism and loving service, as his did. This view, often called incarnational mission, has been very influential, especially among churches working among the poor.

Andreas Köstenberger, in The Missions of Jesus and the Disciples according to the Fourth Gospel (1998), argued the other side carefully. He pointed out that in John, Jesus' mission is unique in ways ours can never be. He is the eternal Word made flesh (John 1:14), the only one who has seen the Father (1:18), the Lamb who takes away the sin of the world. We cannot be incarnated, and we do not atone for anyone. In John, the disciples' role is more like that of witnesses who bear testimony to Jesus, and of followers who do the works he gives them, than of people who repeat his incarnation. Köstenberger and others warned that the language of incarnational mission can blur the uniqueness of Christ and shift the focus from the message about him to the messenger's own presence and service.

Both sides have texts, and both sides have pastoral wisdom on their side. Stott's view takes seriously that Jesus' life is meant to shape his followers' lives: 'whoever believes in Me will also do the works that I am doing' (John 14:12), and 'By this everyone will know that you are My disciples, if you love one another' (13:35). It guards against a mission that speaks but does not love. Köstenberger's view takes seriously that John's Gospel was written 'so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God' (20:31), and that the disciples are sent above all to bear witness to him. It guards against a mission that serves but never names the one it serves. Most writers on both sides would agree that the church is sent into the world, that its life and its words must both point to Jesus, and that it cannot do what only Jesus did. What is debated is whether the manner of Jesus' sending is the template for the church's mission, or whether the church's mission is a distinct task of witness that his life inspires but does not define.

This is the same question you met in lesson 1 and lesson 3, from another angle. Is evangelism the heart of the church's mission, with service as its fruit and its companion? Or are evangelism and service two inseparable parts of one mission modelled on Jesus? You will meet the argument again at Lausanne in module 3 and in practice in module 5. A wise leader learns to hear what each side is protecting.

5. Does the commission still bind? Carey's case and its critics

For many centuries Christians did not treat Matthew 28 as their particular marching orders. Some, especially in the century after the Reformation, argued that the commission had been given to the apostles alone, and that the apostles had carried the gospel to the whole known world in their own lifetime. Some later Calvinists in England went further, worrying that urging the unconverted to believe intruded on God's sovereign work of election. Not all of these objections came from indifference. Some came from a sincere fear of doing in human strength what only God can do.

In 1792 a Baptist shoemaker and pastor in Leicestershire, William Carey, published a pamphlet with a long title, beginning An Enquiry into the Obligations of Christians, to use Means for the Conversion of the Heathens. Its first section bears the heading: 'An Enquiry whether the Commission given by our Lord to his Disciples be not still binding on us.' Carey's argument, in summary, ran like this. If the command to teach all nations was given only to the apostles, then so was the command to baptise in the same sentence, and no church believed that baptism had ended with the apostles. The promise attached to the commission, that Jesus would be with them to the end of the age, could not belong only to men who died in the first century, so the command it was attached to could not either. And the excuses that the heathen were too far away, too dangerous or too uncivilised had not stopped traders from reaching them. Carey's pamphlet then surveyed the population and religion of every country he could find information on, and proposed that Christians form a society to send missionaries. The Baptist Missionary Society was founded that same year, and Carey sailed for India in 1793. Module 3 tells that story in full.

A story is often told about Carey from a few years earlier: that when he raised the question of the commission at a meeting of ministers, an older minister, usually named as John Ryland senior, told him to sit down, because when God pleased to convert the heathen he would do it without Carey's help. The story comes from later recollections, its wording varies, and members of the Ryland family disputed it. It may preserve the mood of the objection Carey faced. It should not be told as a verified quotation.

Since Carey, many Protestant evangelicals have treated Matthew 28:19-20 as the central text of mission, the explicit order of the risen Lord that every church must obey. Its defenders argue that obedience to a clear command is exactly what a comfortable church needs, since a church that waits until it feels like going will never go. They point out that Jesus himself ties love to obedience: 'If you love Me, you will keep My commandments' (John 14:15). A command does not make love unnecessary; it gives love a direction.

Others have argued at full strength that grounding mission chiefly in a command is too narrow. In Pentecost and Missions (1961), the Reformed missiologist Harry Boer pointed out that the book of Acts never shows the apostles quoting the Great Commission as their reason for preaching. They speak because they cannot stop: 'we cannot stop speaking about what we have seen and heard' (Acts 4:20). Boer argued that the church's missionary drive came from the gift of the Spirit at Pentecost, and that the commission functions as the law of the church's own life rather than as an external order it must remember to obey. Christopher Wright makes a related point from the whole Bible: if mission is rooted only in one command at the end of one Gospel, it can look like an afterthought, whereas the commission is better read as the summary of a purpose that runs from Genesis 12 onward. Those who stress the command reply that Pentecost and the commission belong together, since the risen Jesus himself linked them, and that the command keeps the Spirit's impulse from drifting.

What is settled is that the commission still applies. No major Christian tradition today holds that it ended with the apostles, and Carey's argument from the promise of presence has been widely accepted. What is genuinely debated is whether mission rests most deeply on the command of Christ, on the nature of God and his purpose in the whole of scripture, or on the Spirit's work in the church, and how these are related. The answer shapes how you will teach mission in your church. A church that only hears 'you must go' may grow guilty and tired. A church that only hears 'mission is who we are' may never get round to going. The commission itself holds authority, command and presence together.

6. This week: page four, how we make disciples

On page four of your mission plan write: How we make disciples. Write Matthew 28:19-20 at the top. This page is an honest look at what your church does with the people who come to faith, and one step to do it better. Do not write the names of any individuals on this page.

First, divide the page into three columns: Going, Baptising, Teaching to obey. Under Going, write what your church does to take the gospel beyond its own members: outreach, visits, conversations, anything regular. Under Baptising, write how a new believer becomes part of the church: baptism, membership, being welcomed into a home group or a family. Under Teaching to obey, write what happens after that: what new believers are taught, who teaches them, and how anyone knows whether they are putting it into practice. Some columns will be fuller than others. Circle the thinnest.

Second, go back to what you wrote in the inquiry about the last person who came to faith through your church. Compare it with Acts 14:21-23, where Paul and Barnabas made disciples, went back to strengthen them, encouraged them to continue, warned them of hardship, and appointed leaders. Write down which of those things your church did, and which it did not.

Third, write a simple plan to fill the thinnest column. If it is Teaching to obey, a good start is this: invite one or two people who are new in faith to meet with you once a week for eight weeks. Each time, read one passage from Matthew 5 to 7 aloud together. Ask three questions: What does this say? What does it tell us about Jesus? What will we each obey this week? The next week, begin by asking how the obeying went. That is a discipleship pattern a believer with a Bible and a phone can lead anywhere, and it multiplies, because those you teach can do the same with others, as 2 Timothy 2:2 describes. Write down when and where you will start, and pray for the people you hope to invite without writing their names.

Key terms

matheteuoGreek
To make a disciple, or to be discipled. The one imperative verb in Matthew 28:19-20, used only four times in the New Testament (Matthew 13:52, 27:57, 28:19; Acts 14:21). From mathetes, a learner who attaches himself to a teacher to become like him.
Attendant circumstance participleEnglish
A Greek participle that comes before a main imperative and describes an action that must happen first, sharing its force. Grammarians such as Daniel Wallace read 'go' in Matthew 28:19 this way, so that it is a real command, not merely 'as you go', while the main weight falls on making disciples.
panta ta ethneGreek
All the nations. The scope of the commission in Matthew 28:19, echoing Genesis 12:3 and Daniel 7:14. Scholars have debated whether it means the Gentiles as distinct from Israel or every people including Israel; many now take the wider sense, though the narrower one is still defended.
Push on this with the AI Theology Tutor. It already knows what this lesson argued.

Knowledge check

The lesson discusses the grammar of Matthew 28:19, where 'go' is a participle and 'make disciples' is the only imperative. What conclusion does it draw?