Logosphere Bible Institute
--

Lesson 3 · 25 min

Learning to Listen

Most pastoral failures are not failures of doctrine but of hearing. This lesson starts with the God who hears, sits for seven days with Job's friends before watching them ruin it, follows Jesus as He asks questions of people He could have simply told, and then teaches the plain skills of listening well, including how to listen across culture and language and when what you hear means you must act.

My beloved brothers, understand this: Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to anger.

James 1:19 · BSB

Before you read

Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.

  1. Observe

    Read Job 2:11-13. List every action the three friends take, in order, from the moment they hear of Job's trouble to the end of chapter 2. Then read Job 3:1 and 4:1-2. Write down who speaks first after the silence, and who speaks second.

  2. Hear it then

    Read Genesis 50:10 and Ezekiel 3:15, then read Job 2:13 again. What do these three passages share in the length of time and the manner of sitting with sorrow? What does that suggest about how a first reader would have understood the friends' seven days of silence?

  3. Find the problem

    Read Job 4:7-8, 8:4-6 and 11:6. Write in your own words the rule about suffering that each of these speeches assumes. Then read Job 42:7-8. What problem does God's verdict create for a reader who thinks the friends were simply a little too blunt, but basically right?

  4. Weigh the words

    Using Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, look up the Hebrew verb shama in Deuteronomy 6:4, the beginning of the Shema, and in 1 Samuel 3:10. Then look at how the same verb is translated in a few other places where it is listed. What range of meaning does this one Hebrew word carry, and what does that suggest about what biblical listening involves?

  5. Show the evidence

    Someone says: a good pastor always has the right verse ready, and sitting silent with a suffering person is a failure of faith. Test the claim against Job 2:13, Ecclesiastes 3:7, Romans 12:15, John 11:33-35 and Proverbs 25:20. Then test it from the other side against Isaiah 50:4, Proverbs 15:23 and Luke 24:25-27. What does the whole evidence suggest about words and silence?

  6. Why it matters

    Think of a time when you tried to tell someone about something painful and felt you were not heard. Without writing anyone's name, write down what the other person did that made you feel unheard. Then write, honestly, which of those things you also tend to do.

1. The God who hears

Listening is not first a counselling technique. It is something God does. When Israel groaned in Egypt, 'God heard their groaning, and He remembered His covenant' (Exodus 2:24), and at the burning bush He told Moses, 'I have heard them crying out because of their oppressors, and I am aware of their sufferings' (Exodus 3:7). Hagar, a runaway slave woman in the desert, named Him 'the God who sees me' (Genesis 16:13). The psalms are full of people asking God to hear them, and the whole book assumes He will. Before a pastor listens to anyone, he has been listened to by God. That is both the model and the motive. We listen because we are the people of a God who listens.

James puts the rule plainly: 'Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to anger' (James 1:19). The setting is not counselling but the whole life of a church under trial (1:2), and the next verse gives the reason: 'man's anger does not bring about the righteousness that God desires' (1:20). James returns to the tongue again and again. 'If anyone considers himself religious and yet does not bridle his tongue, he deceives his heart and his religion is worthless' (1:26). 'We all stumble in many ways' (3:2), and the tongue is where most of us stumble first. James is not writing about pastors in particular, though in 3:1 he warns teachers that they will be judged more strictly. He is writing to everyone, which is why listening belongs to the whole church's care and not only to the pastor's.

The order matters. Quick to listen comes before slow to speak. Most of us are the other way round: quick to speak and slow to listen, and in a pastor the habit is made worse by the role. People expect the pastor to have an answer, and he wants to give one, and so he starts preparing his reply while the other person is still talking. Proverbs names the result: 'He who answers a matter before he hears it - this is folly and disgrace to him' (Proverbs 18:13). Ecclesiastes says the same about prayer: 'Do not be quick to speak' (5:2). And Isaiah's Servant, the one who will 'sustain the weary with a word', has His ear awakened before His tongue is used: 'He awakens My ear to listen as a disciple' (Isaiah 50:4). The tongue that comforts the weary is the tongue of someone who has first listened.

Hebrew has a word that shows how deep this goes. Shama means to hear, and it is the first word of Israel's great confession, 'Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is One' (Deuteronomy 6:4). But shama is often translated obey. To hear, in the Bible, is to let what you hear reach you and change what you do. Pastoral listening is the same. It is not waiting politely for your turn. It is letting another person's words actually arrive, so that what you say next, if you say anything, is shaped by them and not by what you had already decided to say.

2. Presence before advice: Job's friends

The book of Job contains the Bible's best example of pastoral presence and its most famous example of pastoral failure, and they are done by the same three men. Read Job 2:11-13 slowly. When they heard of Job's trouble, each came from his home, and 'they met together to go and sympathize with Job and comfort him' (2:11). They made a plan and a journey. When they saw him, 'they could barely recognize Job. They began to weep aloud, and each man tore his robe and threw dust in the air over his head' (2:12). They did not hide their shock or their grief. Then: 'they sat on the ground with him for seven days and seven nights, but no one spoke a word to him because they saw how intense his suffering was' (2:13).

That is presence. They came, they wept, they sat on the ground where he was, and they did not speak. Seven days was the length of formal mourning, the period Joseph mourned his father (Genesis 50:10), and Ezekiel too 'sat where they sat' among the exiles for seven days, overwhelmed (Ezekiel 3:15). The friends treated Job as one treats the bereaved, and in their silence they honoured the size of his suffering. Notice also who spoke first. It was Job (3:1), and only after he had poured out his lament did Eliphaz answer (4:1). For a week they let the sufferer set the pace. Any pastor who has visited a house where a child has died and has had the sense to sit quietly, weep, make tea, and wait, has done what Job's friends did best.

Then they began to talk, and the argument that follows runs for nearly thirty chapters. Eliphaz: 'Who, being innocent, has ever perished?' (4:7). Bildad, to a man whose children had just been killed: 'When your children sinned against Him, He gave them over to their rebellion' (8:4). Zophar: 'God exacts from you less than your iniquity deserves' (11:6). Each speech applies a true-sounding rule, that the righteous prosper and the wicked suffer, to a man they had not actually listened to. Job's replies are the cry of someone not being heard. 'You, however, smear with lies; you are all worthless physicians. If only you would remain silent; for that would be your wisdom!' (13:4-5). 'Miserable comforters are you all' (16:2). And, most simply: 'Listen carefully to my words; let this be your consolation to me' (21:2). He did not ask them for an answer. He asked them to listen.

At the end of the book God gives His verdict, and it is not the one a reader might expect. He does not say the friends were right but tactless. He says to Eliphaz, 'My wrath is kindled against you and your two friends. For you have not spoken about Me accurately, as My servant Job has' (42:7). The comforters who defended God's justice were judged to have spoken wrongly of Him, and the sufferer who argued with God was not. Job himself must pray for them (42:8). Pastors should feel the weight of this. The friends' mistake was not that they believed God is just. It was that they explained a man's suffering before they understood it, and so used true things to say false ones. That is the danger every pastor carries into every hospital room.

3. Jesus the listener, and a priest who got it wrong

Jesus could read hearts, and still He asked questions. On the road to Emmaus He joins two grieving disciples and asks, 'What are you discussing so intently as you walk along?' (Luke 24:17). They stop, 'with sadness on their faces', and one of them is almost rude: are you the only visitor to Jerusalem who does not know? Jesus' answer is two words: 'What things?' (24:19). He knows exactly what things; He was the one crucified. But He lets them tell it, all of it, their hope, their confusion, the women's report, the empty tomb (24:19-24). Only then does He speak, and when He does He speaks strongly, calling them 'slow of heart to believe' and opening all the scriptures to them (24:25-27). Listening came first. It did not replace teaching; it prepared for it. Afterwards they said their hearts had burned as He spoke (24:32), and part of the reason is that He spoke to the grief they had actually told Him.

The pattern repeats. A blind man calls out on the Jericho road, and Jesus asks, 'What do you want Me to do for you?' (Mark 10:51). The need seems obvious, but Jesus lets the man name it himself. On the way to the house of a dying girl, with a crowd pressing in and a desperate father waiting, Jesus stops and asks, 'Who touched My garments?' (Mark 5:30). The disciples think it a foolish question. But He 'kept looking around to see who had done this' (5:32), and the woman who had bled for twelve years 'came and fell down before Him trembling in fear, and she told Him the whole truth' (5:33). In the middle of an emergency Jesus made room for one frightened woman to tell her whole story, and then He called her 'Daughter' (5:34). She had come to be healed in secret. She went home healed and heard.

Set beside these a priest who listened badly. Hannah was praying in the house of the LORD at Shiloh, in deep distress over her childlessness. 'Eli watched her mouth' (1 Samuel 1:12), and because her lips moved without sound, 'Eli thought she was drunk' (1:13) and rebuked her: 'How long will you be drunk? Put away your wine!' (1:14). He watched, but he did not listen; he saw behaviour and supplied his own explanation. Hannah corrected him with great dignity: 'I am a woman troubled in spirit... I have poured out my soul before the LORD' (1:15). And to his credit Eli heard her, changed his mind, and blessed her: 'Go in peace' (1:17). Every pastor will misread someone. What matters is whether, when the person tells him he has got it wrong, he stops and listens.

In 1939 Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who had been training pastors in an illegal seminary of the Confessing Church in Germany, published Life Together. In its chapter on ministry he wrote that the first service Christians owe one another is to listen, just as love of God begins with listening to His word. He warned that many Christians, and pastors especially, think they must always contribute something when they are with others, and so they talk when they should listen. And he added a sharper warning: that a person who can no longer listen to his brother will soon no longer be listening to God either, and will be doing nothing but talking, even in his prayers. Bonhoeffer was not a counsellor. He was a theologian training pastors under a hostile regime, and he thought listening was a spiritual discipline before it was a skill.

4. The craft of listening

Listening can be learned, and the methods are simple to describe and hard to practise. The approach often called reflective or active listening came largely from the psychologist Carl Rogers and has been taught to counsellors, nurses, chaplains and teachers for decades. It has five plain parts. First, ask open questions, ones that cannot be answered yes or no. Not 'Are you all right?' but 'How have the last few days been for you?' Not 'Did the doctor give you bad news?' but 'What did the doctor say?' Jesus' 'What things?' is an open question. Second, let people finish. Do not interrupt to correct a detail, to finish their sentence, or to tell your own story. Third, reflect back what you have heard, both the content and the feeling: 'So since the funeral the house has felt empty, and the evenings are the worst.' This shows that the words have arrived, and lets the person correct you if you have heard wrongly.

Fourth, summarise from time to time, especially before you speak at any length yourself: 'Let me check I've understood. You are worried about money, you feel your brothers have left you to carry your mother alone, and underneath that you are not sure God has noticed.' A good summary is often the moment a person feels heard for the first time. Fifth, tolerate silence. When someone stops speaking, they are often thinking, or gathering courage for the thing that is really on their heart. A pastor who fills every pause with words will never hear the second thing, which is usually the important one. Count slowly to ten before you speak into a silence. It will feel very long. It is usually just long enough.

There are habits to unlearn too. Do not say 'I know exactly how you feel'; you do not, and the person knows you do not. Do not top their story with your own, even with the kind intention of showing you understand. Do not rush to explain why it happened, which is what Job's friends did. Do not reach for a verse to close the conversation, as if scripture were a way of making the pain stop talking; the next module has a whole lesson on how to bring scripture to the bedside well. Do not be anxious to fix. Many things a pastor hears cannot be fixed, and the person did not expect them to be. They needed to say them to someone who would not look away.

Listening also means watching. The counselling writer Gerard Egan, in The Skilled Helper, taught generations of students to attend with the whole body, facing the person, keeping an open posture, leaning in a little, keeping appropriate eye contact and staying relaxed. Those particular signals are shaped by one culture, as the next section says, but the principle is universal: people know whether you are attending to them from your body before they hear your words. Put your phone away, out of sight. Sit at the same level as the person, not standing over a bed. Notice what their body is saying too: the clenched hands, the glance at the door, the moment they stop looking at you.

Finally, know when listening must turn into acting. Sometimes what you hear is a danger: a person who speaks of wanting to die, a child who tells you someone is hurting them, a woman who is afraid of her husband. In those moments you must not simply listen and leave, and you must not promise to keep it secret. For that reason, never begin a conversation by promising absolute confidentiality. Say instead something like, 'What you tell me stays with me, unless I'm worried that you or someone else is not safe; then I'll need to get help, and I'll tell you first.' The laws on what must be reported differ from country to country, and you will need to learn yours, but whatever your law says, a promise of confidence must never be used to keep a child at risk hidden. Module 2 deals with confidentiality and Module 5 with what to do in a crisis. For now, the rule is simple: listen fully, and never alone carry what puts a life in danger.

5. Listening across culture and language

Much of what is taught about listening was worked out in North American and European consulting rooms, and it does not all travel. In many cultures steady eye contact with an elder, a pastor or someone of the opposite sex is disrespectful, and lowering the eyes is a sign of honour. Sitting squarely facing someone can feel confrontational where people talk side by side. Leaning in can be an intrusion. The principle under Egan's list is attention, and attention looks different in Accra, Manila, São Paulo and Glasgow. The pastor's task is to learn how attention and respect are shown in his own people, and to show them that way. If you serve people from a culture other than your own, ask a trusted member of that community how a respected visitor is expected to behave, and then do it.

Many people do not speak about painful things directly. They speak in proverbs, stories, hints or questions about someone else. A man who asks his pastor what the Bible says about a friend whose wife has left him may be the friend. A woman who mentions that her neighbour's husband drinks may be telling you about her own house. A listener who only hears the literal words will miss what is being said. Listen for the second meaning, and make it safe for the person to say it more plainly if they want to, without forcing it: 'That sounds hard for your friend. If anyone you know is in that situation, I'd be glad to talk.' In honour cultures a person may never say the real thing in front of family, and a visit to the whole household, however warm, may not give them the chance. You may need to make a second, quieter opportunity.

Language matters more than most pastors realise. People grieve, confess and pray in the language of their heart, usually the language they spoke as children. At Pentecost the crowd was astonished 'because each one heard them speaking his own language' (Acts 2:6). When Paul addressed a hostile crowd in Jerusalem in their own tongue, 'they became even more quiet' (Acts 22:2). A pastor who can only offer care in a second language, the language of school or government, may find people answer politely and say nothing that matters. If you do not speak someone's heart language, find a trustworthy person who does. Be careful who that is. Do not use a child to interpret for an adult in a painful or private matter, and be cautious about using a family member, since the person may not be able to speak freely in front of them, and the interpreter may change what is said. Wherever possible use someone who is trusted, mature and able to keep a confidence, and speak to the person, not to the interpreter.

Grief and distress are also expressed differently. In some places loud wailing is the proper honour paid to the dead, as when Joseph's household 'lamented and wailed loudly' (Genesis 50:10), and a pastor who asks mourners to be quiet has insulted them. In other places tears are held back in public and shed only in private, and a pastor who presses people to express their feelings has shamed them. Neither is more spiritual. Listen to how your people grieve before you decide how they should. And remember propriety and safety in every culture. When listening to someone alone, especially someone of the opposite sex or a young person, sit where others can see you, leave a door open or have another trusted adult nearby, and follow your church's safeguarding policy. Care that puts the person or the pastor at risk is not care.

6. This week: listen, then write your third page

This week, practise on someone safe. Ask a willing adult in your household or a friend, not someone in crisis, to give you fifteen minutes. Ask one open question, such as 'What has been the hardest part of this year for you?', and then for ten minutes do nothing but listen: no advice, no stories of your own, no verses. Reflect back what you hear at least three times, and summarise once at the end. Count to ten in every silence. Then ask them two questions: 'Did you feel heard?' and 'Was there a moment when you felt I wasn't listening?' Write their answers down, without their name.

Then turn to the third page of your care plan and write at the top: How I listen. Write first the bad habits you noticed in yourself, in the inquiry and in the exercise: interrupting, topping, explaining, fixing, filling silences. Name them honestly. Under them write three open questions, in the language your people speak at home, that you can use at the start of a visit to someone who is suffering. Make them natural in your own speech, not translations of the examples here.

Next, write a few lines on how respect and attention are shown in your culture: where a visitor sits, whether to look someone in the eye, how grief is properly expressed, who in a household speaks first. If your church includes people from another culture or language, write down what you need to learn about theirs, and how you will find a trustworthy interpreter if one is needed. Write roles, not names.

Last, copy out the sentence you will use instead of promising secrecy, in your own words and your own language: that what people tell you stays with you unless someone is not safe, and that if that happens you will get help and tell them first. Learn it by heart. Then copy James 1:19 at the bottom of the page. You will come back to this page before every hard visit for the rest of this track.

Key terms

shamaHebrew
To hear, listen, heed or obey. The first word of the Shema, 'Hear, O Israel' (Deuteronomy 6:4). In biblical thought you have not truly heard until what you heard has reached you and shaped what you do.
Reflective listeningEnglish
A way of listening that asks open questions, lets the speaker finish, reflects back both what was said and what was felt, summarises, and tolerates silence. Developed largely from the work of Carl Rogers, it shows the speaker that their words have arrived and lets them correct a listener who has heard wrongly.
PresenceEnglish
Being with a suffering person in a way that honours the size of their suffering before trying to explain or relieve it. Job's friends practised it for seven days (Job 2:13) and then abandoned it for speeches God judged untrue (Job 42:7).
Push on this with the AI Theology Tutor. It already knows what this lesson argued.

Knowledge check

Job's friends sat with him in silence for seven days and then spoke at length. According to the lesson, what was the heart of their failure?