Logosphere Bible Institute
--

Lesson 1 · 24 min

What Pastoral Care Is

Before a pastor visits anyone, he needs to know what he is going there to do. This lesson follows the shepherd through scripture, from the indictment of Israel's leaders in Ezekiel 34 to the Good Shepherd of John 10 and Peter's charge to the elders, names the old tradition of the care of souls, and asks who in a church is meant to do it. It ends with the first page of a care plan for your own congregation.

Be shepherds of God's flock that is among you, watching over them not out of compulsion, but willingly, as God would have you; not out of greed, but out of eagerness; not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock.

1 Peter 5:2-3 · BSB

Before you read

Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.

  1. Observe

    Read Ezekiel 34:1-16. Make two columns. In the first, list every specific thing the shepherds of Israel are accused of doing or failing to do (34:2-6). In the second, list every specific thing the Lord says He Himself will do (34:11-16). Copy the verbs exactly and note the verse for each.

  2. Notice

    Read 1 Peter 5:1-4. Write down every title Peter gives himself in verse 1 and the title he gives Christ in verse 4. Then write down what verse 2 says the flock belongs to. What do those titles and that possessive word tell the elders about their own position?

  3. Hear it then

    From Psalm 23, John 10:1-16, Luke 15:4 and 1 Samuel 17:34-35, build a picture of an ordinary shepherd's working day and night in ancient Israel. List what he does, where he goes, and what dangers he faces. Which of these tasks would a first-century reader of 1 Peter have recognised from life rather than from books?

  4. Weigh the words

    Using Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, both free, look up the Greek verb behind 'lording it over' in 1 Peter 5:3. Find the other places in the New Testament where the same verb occurs, and read each one in its setting. What kind of power does this word describe, and where did Jesus say it belongs?

  5. Show the evidence

    Someone in your church says: caring for the hurting is the pastor's job, and members should simply call him when someone is in trouble. Test the claim against Galatians 6:1-2, 1 Thessalonians 5:14, Romans 15:14, 1 Corinthians 12:25-26 and Ephesians 4:11-12. Then test it from the other side against Acts 20:28 and 1 Peter 5:2. What does the evidence support, and what does it not?

  6. Why it matters

    Think of a time when you were in real trouble and someone in the church cared for you well. Without writing any name, write down what that person actually did and said, and what they did not do. Then write one sentence on which of those things you could do for someone else this month.

1. What we mean by pastoral care

Start with a working definition, so that the whole track has something to test. Pastoral care is the work of the church, through its shepherds and its members, of watching over people as souls for whom Christ died: seeking them when they wander, staying with them when they suffer, guiding them when they are lost, and bringing them back to God and to one another when they have fallen out with both. Every part of that sentence will be tested in this track. But it gives you four things to hold. Pastoral care belongs to the church, not to one gifted person. It concerns the whole person before God, not only their feelings or only their doctrine. It is mostly done in ordinary places and ordinary hours. And its aim is not to make people comfortable but to keep them, and bring them home, as God's own flock.

In 1964 two American scholars, the church historian William Clebsch and Charles Jaekle, published Pastoral Care in Historical Perspective, and the scheme they proposed has shaped teaching ever since. Reading two thousand years of Christian letters, sermons and manuals, they found four functions recurring. Healing restores a person towards wholeness after damage. Sustaining helps a person endure what cannot be changed, which is most of what a pastor does at a deathbed or with chronic illness. Guiding helps a person choose well when the way is unclear. Reconciling restores broken relationships with God and with neighbour, through confession, forgiveness and the discipline of the church. Later writers added others. Howard Clinebell, in his textbook on pastoral care and counselling, added nurturing, the steady growth of people over time. The Ghanaian scholar Emmanuel Lartey, writing for churches beyond the West, is among those who have argued that care must also liberate and empower, because care that comforts people inside an unjust situation without ever naming the injustice is not finished.

The scheme is useful because it stops a pastor reducing care to one thing. A pastor who only ever guides will give advice to people who needed to be sustained. A pastor who only ever sustains will sit kindly with someone who needed to be reconciled to a brother. And a pastor who only ever reconciles will turn every hospital visit into a call to repentance. When you leave a visit, ask yourself which of the functions that person most needed, and which one you actually offered.

It also helps to say what pastoral care is not. It is not the same as preaching, though good preaching is caring and the preacher who never visits will preach to people he does not know. It is not the same as counselling, though counselling is one form of it: counselling is usually a series of planned conversations about a particular problem, and most pastoral care is not like that. It is a visit, a meal, a prayer at the door, a message on a phone, a funeral, a hand on a shoulder in the car park. And it is not the same as solving people's problems. Many of the problems a pastor meets cannot be solved at all, and some must be handed to doctors, lawyers or the police. This track will be very plain about that in Module 5. A pastor who thinks his task is to fix everyone will either break, or start pretending he has fixed people he has not.

2. The LORD is my shepherd: the image in the Old Testament

The word pastor is simply the Latin for shepherd, and the Bible's language for leaders of God's people is drawn from the sheepfold before it is drawn from anywhere else. The image is older than Israel. In the ancient Near East kings routinely called themselves shepherds of their people: the prologue to the laws of Hammurabi, king of Babylon in the eighteenth century BC, presents him as the shepherd called by the gods. To say that a ruler is a shepherd was to say that he was responsible for the welfare of those under him. What Israel's scriptures do with that common image is to give the title first to God.

'The LORD is my shepherd; I shall not want' (Psalm 23:1). The psalm is not a description of a pleasant afternoon. It moves from green pastures and quiet waters to 'the valley of the shadow of death' (23:4), and the comfort in the valley is not that the danger has gone but 'for You are with me'. Isaiah gives the same God a tenderness that every pastor should study: 'He tends His flock like a shepherd; He gathers the lambs in His arms and carries them close to His heart. He gently leads the nursing ewes' (Isaiah 40:11). The weakest members of the flock set the pace. A shepherd who drives the nursing ewes at the speed of the strong rams will lose them.

Against that picture the prophets measured Israel's leaders, and found them wanting. Jeremiah begins his charge, 'Woe to the shepherds who destroy and scatter the sheep of My pasture!' (Jeremiah 23:1). Ezekiel 34 is the fullest indictment. The shepherds 'only feed themselves' (34:2); they eat the fat, wear the wool and butcher the fattened sheep (34:3). Then comes the verse every pastor should know by heart, because it is a job description written in the negative: 'You have not strengthened the weak, healed the sick, bound up the injured, brought back the strays, or searched for the lost. Instead, you have ruled them with violence and cruelty' (34:4). Notice what is condemned. It is not mainly bad doctrine. It is neglect: five tasks of care left undone, and a sixth thing done in their place, rule by force.

Then God answers. 'Behold, I Myself will search for My flock and seek them out' (34:11). And at the end of the passage, the list from verse 4 comes back almost word for word, now as a promise: 'I will seek the lost, bring back the strays, bind up the broken, and strengthen the weak' (34:16). This is the most important thing to see in the chapter. God does not describe a different kind of care from the one the shepherds neglected. He does the very same tasks Himself. The job description for a human shepherd is simply what God does with His own flock. Pastoral care is not a technique a church invents; it is a share in the way God already treats His people.

The passage does not end with God abolishing human shepherds. 'I will appoint over them one shepherd, My servant David, and he will feed them' (34:23), and Jeremiah has the same promise: 'I will raise up shepherds over them who will tend them' (Jeremiah 23:4). The Christian church has read the promised David as Christ, and the further shepherds of Jeremiah 23:4 as those He would raise up under Him. Proverbs adds a piece of ordinary farm wisdom that turns out to be pastoral method: 'Be sure to know the state of your flocks, and pay close attention to your herds' (Proverbs 27:23). You cannot care for a flock you have never counted.

3. The Good Shepherd and His under-shepherds

When Jesus says 'I am the good shepherd' (John 10:11), He is stepping into Ezekiel 34. The listeners who knew the prophets would have heard the claim: the shepherd God promised to be, and the David God promised to send, are standing in front of them. Jesus fills the image with three things a pastor must not forget. First, He knows the sheep personally: 'He calls his own sheep by name and leads them out' (10:3), and 'I know My sheep and My sheep know Me' (10:14). Care is not delivered to a crowd. Second, He goes ahead of them: 'he goes on ahead of them, and his sheep follow him because they know his voice' (10:4). He leads from the front, not by driving from behind. Third, He gives Himself: 'The good shepherd lays down His life for the sheep' (10:11).

Set against Him is the hired hand. 'The hired hand is not the shepherd, and the sheep are not his own. When he sees the wolf coming, he abandons the sheep and runs away' (10:12). The next verse gives the reason in one plain line: 'The man runs away because he is a hired servant and is unconcerned for the sheep' (10:13). The difference between a shepherd and a hired hand is not that one is paid and the other is not. Paul insists that those who preach may receive their living from it (1 Corinthians 9:14). The difference shows when the wolf comes. A hired hand cares for the sheep while it costs him nothing.

The Gospels show what moved Jesus to this work. 'When He saw the crowds, He was moved with compassion for them, because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd' (Matthew 9:36). In Luke 15 He asks which man with a hundred sheep would not 'leave the ninety-nine in the pasture and go after the one that is lost, until he finds it' (15:4). The verse is easy to sentimentalise. Pastorally it is hard. It means the one who has stopped coming matters as much as the ninety-nine who fill the building on Sunday, and that a pastor's week should contain time for the one.

After the resurrection Jesus hands this work on, and He hands it to a man who has recently failed Him. Three times He asks Peter, 'do you love Me?', and three times He gives a charge: 'Feed My lambs', 'Shepherd My sheep', 'Feed My sheep' (John 21:15-17). Twice the sheep are called 'My'. Peter is not given his own flock; he is trusted with Christ's. The New Testament keeps the title of shepherd for Christ in its fullest sense. He is 'that great Shepherd of the sheep' (Hebrews 13:20), and in Peter's own letter He is 'the Chief Shepherd' (1 Peter 5:4). Every human pastor is an under-shepherd. That is a humbling title and a freeing one. The flock is not finally yours to save, and you will give it back.

4. Reading the anchor: three contrasts

First Peter was written to scattered Christians in the provinces of what is now Turkey, under pressure and the threat of worse (1 Peter 4:12). Chapter 5 turns to their leaders. Peter writes 'As a fellow elder' (5:1), and the Greek word, sympresbyteros, occurs nowhere else in the New Testament. An apostle could have written as a superior; he chose to stand beside them. He is the man to whom Jesus said 'Shepherd My sheep', and now he passes the same verb on: 'Be shepherds of God's flock that is among you' (5:2). The Greek imperative is poimanate, from poimaino, to tend as a shepherd: to feed, lead, guard and gather. Then, in the reading the BSB follows, a participle explains what shepherding involves: 'watching over them', episkopountes, from the same root as episkopos, overseer. A few important early manuscripts lack the participle, but the idea of oversight is present either way, since Acts 20:28 joins the same two words, overseers and shepherds, for the same people.

Then Peter gives three contrasts, each a temptation the elders will meet. Not 'out of compulsion, but willingly, as God would have you'. Some will shepherd because they were pushed into it, or because there was no one else, or because the family expects it, and their care will have the dull weight of a duty done under protest. The flock can feel the difference. Not 'out of greed, but out of eagerness'. In a church where leaders handled the common fund, and in a culture where religious teachers were often suspected of teaching for profit, Peter knows the risk. Greed in a pastor is not only about money. It can be a hunger for status, for being needed, for being thanked. Eagerness is a readiness to serve that does not keep accounts.

The third contrast is the sharpest: 'not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock' (5:3). The verb is katakyrieuo, the word Jesus used of the rulers of the Gentiles when He said, 'it shall not be this way among you' (Mark 10:42-43). Peter had heard Him say it. The phrase 'those entrusted to you' translates a single Greek word, kleros, which means a share or an allotted portion, the lot that falls to someone. Each elder has been given a portion of God's people to care for, as a man might be given a portion of land, and the land is still the owner's. It is a small irony of church history that the English word clergy descends from kleros, so that a word Peter used for the people entrusted to the leaders came to be used for the leaders themselves.

Instead of lording it, the elders are to be 'examples', typoi, patterns or models that can be traced. The contrast is between two ways of getting a flock to move. You can drive sheep from behind with a stick, or you can walk ahead and let them follow. Ezekiel's shepherds 'ruled them with violence and cruelty' (Ezekiel 34:4); the Good Shepherd 'goes on ahead of them' (John 10:4). Peter's elders lead by being the kind of Christians the flock can watch and copy. This is why the shepherd's own life is not a private matter, and why this module ends, in lesson 4, with the shepherd's own soul.

Then the promise: 'when the Chief Shepherd appears, you will receive the crown of glory that will never fade away' (5:4). Pastoral care is often unseen. Most of it is never thanked and much of it seems to achieve nothing. Peter does not tell the elders their reward will come from the flock. It will come from the one whose flock it is, on the day He appears. That is what makes it possible to keep going.

5. The care of souls, and who does it

For most of its history the church had a name for this work. In Latin it was cura animarum, the care, or cure, of souls. The word cura means both care and responsibility for something, and the old English word cure kept both senses: a parish priest had the cure of souls in his parish, and an assistant priest was called a curate, the one who shares the cure. German Protestants call it Seelsorge, soul-care, and still use that as the ordinary word for pastoral care. Do not let the word soul mislead you. In the Bible the soul is not a ghostly part of a person that floats inside a body. The Hebrew nephesh often means the whole living person, with a throat that thirsts and a life that can be lost. To care for a soul is to care for a person before God, body, mind, relationships and all, as someone who will one day stand before Him.

So who does it? The New Testament answer is both: the whole church, and its appointed shepherds, each in their own way. On one side, the commands to care are given to everyone. 'Carry one another's burdens, and in this way you will fulfill the law of Christ' (Galatians 6:2) is addressed to the brothers of the Galatian churches, not to their elders. 'Admonish the unruly, encourage the fainthearted, help the weak, and be patient with everyone' (1 Thessalonians 5:14) is addressed to the brothers. Paul says of an entire congregation he had never visited that they are 'able to instruct one another' (Romans 15:14). And the body is arranged so 'that its members should have mutual concern for one another. If one part suffers, every part suffers with it' (1 Corinthians 12:25-26).

On the other side, the elders are given a particular charge. 'Keep watch over yourselves and the entire flock of which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers' (Acts 20:28) is not said to every believer. Hebrews tells the church that its leaders 'watch over your souls as those who must give an account' (Hebrews 13:17), which is the subject of the next lesson. And Ephesians 4 holds the two sides together in one sentence: Christ gave 'some to be pastors and teachers, to equip the saints for works of ministry' (4:11-12). The pastor is not the only one who cares. He is the one who sees that caring happens, does the hardest of it himself, and trains the rest of the church to do the rest.

Here the churches genuinely differ, and you should know how. In the Catholic and Orthodox churches certain acts of care belong to the ordained priest: hearing a confession and pronouncing absolution, and anointing the sick, which both churches count among the sacraments. Lay people visit, pray and comfort, but these acts are reserved. Anglicans and many Lutherans also keep private confession with a minister, though they do not require it. The Reformed tradition from Bucer onwards gave the care of souls to a body of elders together with the minister, who divided a parish into districts and visited homes. Baptist, congregational and many Pentecostal churches lay the greatest stress on the mutual care of all members, with pastors as first among them. Each tradition reads the same texts, and each has a reason for its shape: the first stresses that Christ acts through the office He has given; the last stresses that the Spirit is given to every member. This track will name those differences where they matter, especially in Module 2 when we come to the sick.

What is settled across all of them is this. No single pastor can personally carry every member of a congregation, and the New Testament never asks him to. A pastor with three hundred people and a full-time job outside the church who tries to be the only carer will fail them and himself. Churches in many traditions have trained lay members as carers; the Stephen Ministries programme, begun by Kenneth Haugk in the United States in 1975, is one well-known example, and there are many others, formal and informal, across the world. The danger runs the other way too. Untrained, unsupervised care can do harm, especially where there is abuse, suicide risk or serious illness. So the pastor's task is not to do all the caring, nor to hand it all away. It is to know the flock, to do what only a shepherd should do, to equip others for the rest, and to know when to bring in help from outside the church.

6. This week: begin your care plan

This track is built so that by the end you have a written care plan for your own church: who will be visited and by whom, how you will respond to grief and crisis, whom you will refer to, and how you will keep people safe. Every lesson adds a page. Take a notebook that will be used for nothing else, and write on the cover: My Care Plan. On the first page write: The flock in my care.

First, do what Proverbs 27:23 says and know the state of your flock. Do not write anyone's name in this notebook, now or later. A notebook can be lost, borrowed or read, and the people in it have not agreed to be written down. Instead, write categories and numbers. Roughly how many people belong to your church or fellowship? How many are elderly or housebound? How many are widowed? How many are sick in a lasting way? How many children and young people? How many are new in the last year? How many used to come and have stopped? Use your church's own register if there is one, and count from memory if there is not. Where you do not know a number, write a question mark. The question marks are the first thing this page will teach you.

Second, under the numbers, write Ezekiel 34:4 in full, and beside each of its five tasks write one honest sentence about your church: who, if anyone, strengthens the weak, heals the sick, binds up the injured, brings back the strays and searches for the lost. Write roles, not names: the women's fellowship, an elder, a deacon, nobody. Then write one sentence on which of the four functions from section 1, healing, sustaining, guiding and reconciling, your church does best, and which it most neglects.

Third, at the bottom of the page draw a box and label it: Help beyond me. This box will grow through the whole track. Start it today by writing down your country's emergency number and the location of the nearest hospital or clinic. Do not trust a number you remember from somewhere; find it from an official source and check it. Later lessons will add a crisis line, a child-protection contact, a doctor and others. You will be glad of this box on the night you need it, and it is better filled now, in daylight, than then.

Key terms

poimenGreek
Shepherd. Used of Jesus as the good shepherd (John 10:11) and the great Shepherd (Hebrews 13:20), and in Ephesians 4:11 of those Christ gives to the church as pastors. The verb poimaino, to tend as a shepherd, is Jesus' charge to Peter in John 21:16 and Peter's to the elders in 1 Peter 5:2. The Latin pastor means the same thing.
cura animarumLatin
The care, or cure, of souls. The church's historic name for pastoral care, behind the English curate and the German Seelsorge. Cura carries both care and responsibility, and soul in the biblical sense means the whole person living before God, not only the inner life.
klerosGreek
A lot, share or allotted portion. Behind 'those entrusted to you' in 1 Peter 5:3: each elder has a portion of God's people put in his care, and it remains God's. The English word clergy descends from it, by a later shift that applied the word to the leaders instead of the people.
Push on this with the AI Theology Tutor. It already knows what this lesson argued.

Knowledge check

Ezekiel 34:4 lists what the shepherds of Israel failed to do, and 34:16 returns to the same list. According to the lesson, what follows from the way the two verses mirror each other?