Lesson 2 · 27 min
The Care of Souls Through the Centuries
You are not the first pastor to sit with a grieving widow or a man who has fallen. This lesson puts four classic teachers of the care of souls in your hands, Gregory the Great, Martin Bucer and Richard Baxter among them, then sets out the two great modern movements, clinical pastoral education and biblical counselling, each in the form its own best defenders would recognise, and marks where they agree and where they still divide.
Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they watch over your souls as those who must give an account. To this end, allow them to lead with joy and not with grief, for that would be of no advantage to you.
Hebrews 13:17 · BSB
Before you read
Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.
Observe
Read Hebrews 13 and find the three verses that mention leaders: 13:7, 13:17 and 13:24. For each, write down what the church is told to do, and what, if anything, is said about what the leaders do or did. Then note which of the three looks back to the past and which look at the present.
Hear it then
Read Ezekiel 33:1-9, the charge to the watchman. Write down what the watchman must do, what happens if he does it and the people ignore him, and what happens if he fails to do it. Then read Hebrews 13:17 again. What in the Ezekiel passage helps you hear the phrase 'as those who must give an account'?
Weigh the words
Using Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, look up the Greek verb behind 'watch over' in Hebrews 13:17. Find where else the same verb is used, for example Mark 13:33, Luke 21:36 and Ephesians 6:18. What picture of a leader's watching does this word give, and how is it different from the word for overseer in Acts 20:28?
Weigh the words
Look up the Greek verb noutheteo, which the BSB renders with words like 'admonish', 'instruct' and 'warn'. Read Acts 20:31, Romans 15:14, Colossians 1:28 and 1 Thessalonians 5:14. For each, note who is doing it, to whom, and with what attitude or emotion. What does the word involve that 'teach' alone does not?
Show the evidence
Someone tells you that the old pastors simply told everyone the same truths, and that fitting care to the particular person is a modern idea from psychology. Test the claim against Proverbs 18:13, 1 Thessalonians 5:14, Jude 22-23 and 1 Corinthians 9:22. What do these texts suggest about whether one response suits every person?
Why it matters
Write down where you learned what you know about caring for people in trouble: from a pastor you watched, a parent, a book, a training course, your own suffering, or nowhere in particular. Then write one sentence on what that source taught you well and one on what it may have left out.
1. Those who must give an account
Hebrews 13:17 has been badly used. Leaders who wanted unquestioning obedience have quoted its first words and stopped. Read the whole verse and it is a heavier verse for the leader than for the congregation. The church is told to 'Obey your leaders and submit to them'. The first verb, peithesthe, is from a root meaning to be persuaded, and the second, hypeikete, means to yield or give way. It is a call to be the kind of congregation that can be led, rather than one that resists every guidance on principle. But the reason given is about the leaders' burden: 'for they watch over your souls as those who must give an account.' The verb for watching is agrypneo, to go without sleep. These are leaders who lie awake over their people, and who will answer to God for them.
Behind the phrase stands Ezekiel's watchman, who must blow the horn when he sees the sword coming, and of whom God says, if he fails, 'I will hold the watchman accountable for his blood' (Ezekiel 33:6). The leaders in Hebrews 13 are not owners of the flock but stewards who will report on it. And the verse is set within a chapter that tells the church first to 'Consider the outcome of their way of life and imitate their faith' (13:7). Hebrews does not ask for obedience to anyone who happens to hold office. It asks a congregation to make faithful leadership a joy rather than a grief, and it asks leaders to remember that every person in their care is a soul they will one day give account for.
That sense of accountability is why the church has written so much about how to care for souls. A pastor in a village with no library may think he must work out alone how to visit the dying, rebuke the proud and comfort the despairing. He does not. For sixteen centuries pastors have written down what they learned, and the best of it is now available free or cheaply in translation. In the fourth century Gregory of Nazianzus, after fleeing his own ordination, wrote a long defence of his flight, his second oration, in which he called the guiding of human beings the art of arts and the science of sciences, harder than the physician's art because souls are harder to read than bodies. Probably in the 380s John Chrysostom wrote his dialogue On the Priesthood, explaining why he too had tried to avoid the office. Both men took the care of souls so seriously that they were afraid of it. That fear is the right place to begin.
2. Gregory the Great: one medicine does not suit every illness
Gregory was a Roman aristocrat who had been prefect of the city, gave away his wealth, became a monk, and in 590 was made bishop of Rome much against his will, in a city wasted by plague, flood and war. Within a year or so he wrote a handbook for bishops, the Liber Regulae Pastoralis, the Book of Pastoral Rule, addressed to John, bishop of Ravenna. It became the most influential manual of pastoral care in the Western church for a thousand years. In the ninth century King Alfred of Wessex translated it into Old English and sent a copy to every bishop in his kingdom. Near the start Gregory takes up the line from Gregory of Nazianzus: the government of souls is the art of arts, ars artium regimen animarum. If people will not practise medicine without study, he asks, why do so many take on the care of souls without it?
The Rule has four parts. The first asks who should take up the office and who should not, warning both against those who seize it for status and against those gifted for it who refuse out of love of a quiet life. The second describes the life the pastor must live: pure in thought, an example in action, discreet in silence and useful in speech, close to each person in compassion and above all in contemplation, humble with those who do well and firm against wrongdoing. Gregory says the pastor must not neglect inward things because of outward business, nor neglect outward needs because he is absorbed in inward things. Any pastor who has spent a week so busy with church buildings and meetings that he did not pray, or so absorbed in study that he did not visit, knows what Gregory means.
The third part is the longest and the most original, and it is the reason to read the book. Gregory sets out pair after pair of different kinds of people and how each should be admonished differently: men and women, the young and the old, the poor and the rich, the joyful and the sad, the wise and the dull, the bold and the timid, the patient and the impatient, the healthy and the sick, those who sin in secret and those who sin openly, and many more. His principle is that the same word can heal one person and harm another, as a food that nourishes one creature may kill another. The timid must be encouraged and the impudent rebuked, and if the pastor rebukes the timid as he rebukes the impudent he will crush someone who needed lifting. This is not the invention of psychology. It is what Paul meant by 'admonish the unruly, encourage the fainthearted, help the weak' (1 Thessalonians 5:14), worked out at length by a man who had sat with all of them.
The fourth part is a single short chapter, and it is the one most pastors skip. After all his work, Gregory says, the pastor must return to himself, lest having done well he grow proud, and lest in healing others he neglect his own wounds. He closes by asking John to pray for him, saying that he has tried to paint the portrait of a good shepherd, though he himself is a poor painter far from the picture. The best book on pastoral care in a thousand years ends with its author confessing that he does not match it. That is not false modesty; it is the shape of the work. Lesson 4 of this module comes back to it.
3. Bucer and Baxter: the Reformation goes visiting
The Reformation is usually remembered for its preaching and its doctrine of justification, but its leaders also rebuilt the care of souls. Luther wrote hundreds of letters of spiritual counsel to the bereaved, the sick, the anxious and the dying, and they are still read. In Strasbourg, Martin Bucer, who later ended his life teaching at Cambridge, published in 1538 a book called Von der waren Seelsorge, Concerning the True Care of Souls. It is now available in English, and it deserves to be far better known than it is.
Bucer built his whole scheme on Ezekiel 34:16, and found in it five tasks. The carer of souls must seek the lost, those who have never been brought to Christ or who are wholly estranged; bring back the strays, those who once belonged and have drifted; bind up the broken, those who have fallen into serious sin and need restoration; strengthen the weak, those who belong but are faint and sickly in faith; and keep and feed the healthy and strong, urging them on. Notice the fifth. The Hebrew text the BSB follows reads 'the sleek and strong I will destroy', a judgment on the fat sheep who had trampled the rest (34:20-21). But the Greek Septuagint and the Latin Vulgate, which Bucer knew well, read the verb as guard, and so he drew from the verse a duty of care even to those who are doing well. Whichever reading is right, Bucer's point stands on other texts: the strong also need a shepherd, and a church that only notices people in crisis will lose its healthy members slowly and quietly. Bucer also insisted that this work belonged not to the minister alone but to a body of elders with him, and that discipline, the church's loving correction of members who fall into sin, is itself an act of care. That conviction shaped Reformed churches from Geneva to Scotland.
A century later, in the English market town of Kidderminster, the Puritan pastor Richard Baxter did something few pastors before him had attempted. He and his assistant set out to meet personally with every family in the parish, some eight hundred of them, about fifteen or sixteen families each week, two days of every week, to talk with them about their souls and teach them the faith. In 1656 he published the address he had prepared for a gathering of the ministers of Worcestershire, who had agreed to do the same. He called it Gildas Salvianus, The Reformed Pastor. The word reformed in the title does not mean Calvinist. It means renewed: a pastor whose ministry has been reformed, brought back to its proper work.
The book is an exposition of Acts 20:28, which is the anchor of lesson 4 of this module, and it falls into two halves that match the verse. First, take heed to yourselves: the pastor must be converted, must not live contrary to his own preaching, must keep his own soul alive. Then take heed to all the flock: the pastor must know every person in his charge, and give himself to converting the unconverted, building up the converted, and attending especially to families. Baxter's great argument is that preaching to a crowd is not enough. Many in the pew, he observed, had heard sermons for years and understood little, and a single hour of personal conversation taught them more. He was not against preaching; he was one of the great preachers of his age. He was for knowing people one by one.
These were not the only traditions. In the same century the Catholic Reformation renewed the confessional and the practice of spiritual direction, and Francis de Sales's Introduction to the Devout Life (1609), written from his letters of direction to lay people, is still widely read. The Orthodox churches kept the figure of the spiritual father or elder, a person, often a monk, known for prayer and discernment, to whom believers would go for counsel; in nineteenth-century Russia the elders of the Optina monastery drew visitors from every class. Each tradition gives the care of souls a different shape. All of them assumed it was the church's central work, that it required training and holiness, and that it had to be fitted to the person.
4. The clinical pastoral movement: reading living human documents
The first of the two great modern movements began in a mental hospital. In 1920 an American minister named Anton Boisen suffered an acute psychotic breakdown and spent many months as a patient in a state hospital in Massachusetts. What struck him, when he recovered, was that nobody in that hospital had been able to help him understand what had happened to him spiritually. The doctors treated his illness and the clergy were absent. Boisen came to believe that some episodes of mental illness were, among other things, a soul's desperate attempt to solve a crisis of meaning, and that the church had left these people alone. In 1924 he became chaplain at Worcester State Hospital, and in the summer of 1925 he brought theological students to work on the wards. His phrase for what he wanted them to learn has become famous: to study living human documents, not only the documents in the library.
Boisen was supported by the Boston physician Richard Cabot, who in 1925 published an article pleading for a clinical year in theological training, on the model of medical students learning on hospital wards. Out of their work grew what is now called Clinical Pastoral Education, or CPE. A council for the clinical training of theological students was founded in 1930, and in 1967 several bodies joined to form the Association for Clinical Pastoral Education. The method has hardly changed. A student works as a chaplain in a hospital, prison or care home, writes up real conversations afterwards in detail, often word for word in what is called a verbatim, and then examines them with a supervisor and a small group of peers: what the person said, what the student said, what the student felt, what the student missed. Alongside it grew a body of writing on pastoral counselling, from Seward Hiltner's Pastoral Counseling (1949) to Wayne Oates, a Southern Baptist who taught at Louisville, and Howard Clinebell's Basic Types of Pastoral Counseling (1966). Much of it drew on the psychologist Carl Rogers, who taught counsellors to listen with warmth, accept the person and reflect back what they heard rather than direct.
Its best defenders make a strong case, and it rests on scripture as well as experience. Care must be given to the actual person in front of you, not to a type, and you cannot know that person without listening; Job's friends had sound theology and were rebuked by God for what they said to a suffering man (Job 42:7). Pastors learn to care the way doctors learn to heal, by doing it under supervision and having their mistakes shown to them, and no amount of reading replaces that. The carer's own anxieties, the need to fix, to be thanked, to escape an uncomfortable silence, get in the way of the other person, and must be faced. And what is true about the human mind and body, wherever it is discovered, is God's truth; Augustine argued in On Christian Teaching that a Christian should recognise truth as his Lord's wherever he finds it. To refuse what medicine and psychology have learned about grief, trauma and illness is not faithfulness but neglect. The movement also made it possible for chaplains to serve in hospitals and prisons alongside doctors and staff, where people of every faith and none are dying and need someone to sit with them.
Its critics, including some within the movement, have pressed hard on one point. In A History of Pastoral Care in America (1983) the historian E. Brooks Holifield traced a long shift in American Protestant care, signalled in his subtitle, From Salvation to Self-Realization. Thomas Oden, a Methodist theologian who had himself been formed in that world, observed in the early 1980s that the standard modern pastoral care textbooks cited Freud, Jung and Rogers again and again and the great pastoral writers of the church, Gregory, Chrysostom, Baxter, scarcely at all. The charge is that theology became thin, that sin and grace dropped out of the vocabulary, that the pastor became a therapist with a collar, and that scripture was used for comfort but rarely allowed to speak. Defenders reply that this describes some of the movement's history, not its method; that a verbatim is precisely a way of being honest about what really happened in a visit; that CPE programmes now train chaplains to attend to spiritual and religious need explicitly; and that the alternative to listening well is not orthodoxy but the error of Job's friends. Their answer was not to abandon clinical learning but to recover its theological roots, and Oden himself, the sharpest of the critics, wanted the classical pastors brought back into conversation with clinical learning, not clinical learning thrown away.
5. The biblical counselling movement: competent to counsel
The second movement began as a response to the first. Jay E. Adams was a Presbyterian pastor who taught practical theology at Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia. In the 1960s he became convinced that pastors had handed their own work to psychiatrists and psychologists, and that much of what they were taught about counselling assumed a view of human beings that scripture does not share. In 1965 he spent a summer with the psychologist O. Hobart Mowrer, who had argued in The Crisis in Psychiatry and Religion (1961) that much of what was called mental illness was in fact the result of real guilt over real wrongdoing that had never been faced. Adams welcomed Mowrer's emphasis on responsibility and rejected his humanism, since Mowrer had no Saviour to offer the guilty. In 1970 Adams published Competent to Counsel, taking his title from Romans 15:14, a verse the BSB renders 'able to instruct one another'. With colleagues he had founded the Christian Counseling and Educational Foundation in 1968, and in 1976 the body now called the Association of Certified Biblical Counselors was formed to train and certify counsellors.
Adams called his approach nouthetic counselling, from noutheteo, the verb behind Paul's 'warning each of you night and day with tears' (Acts 20:31) and 'admonishing and teaching everyone with all wisdom' (Colossians 1:28). He described three elements in the word: there is something in a person's life that God wants changed; the change is pursued by personal, verbal confrontation with God's word; and it is done out of love, for the person's own good. Adams did not deny that some problems are physical. He held that illnesses with an organic cause belong to physicians. What he denied was that the deepest troubles of the human heart, guilt, fear, anger, despair, broken relationships, are outside the reach of scripture and the church.
Its best defenders make a strong case, and it too rests on scripture. 'All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for instruction, for conviction, for correction, and for training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be complete, fully equipped for every good work' (2 Timothy 3:16-17). God's 'divine power has given us everything we need for life and godliness through the knowledge of Him' (2 Peter 1:3). If that is true, the church does not need to borrow its basic understanding of the human heart from theories built on other foundations, and no theory of human nature is neutral. People's troubles are, at bottom, troubles before God, and only the gospel addresses guilt with forgiveness rather than with relabelling. The care of souls belongs to the church, not to a profession that the church must refer its members to, and ordinary believers, not only experts, are equipped to do much of it, as Romans 15:14 says. The movement's second generation, writers such as David Powlison, Edward Welch and Paul Tripp, kept these convictions and deepened them: Powlison taught counsellors to look for the desires that rule a person's heart, and Welch, in Blame It on the Brain? (1998), wrote carefully about how body and soul interact in depression and other conditions. Heath Lambert's The Biblical Counseling Movement after Adams (2012) describes this generation as more attentive to suffering, and to the person as sufferer as well as sinner, while keeping Adams's convictions about scripture.
Its critics, including some within the movement, have pressed hard on one point. They argue that Adams's early writing was too quick to treat suffering as sin, too confident that confrontation would work, and too dismissive of what research has learned about conditions such as depression, trauma and psychosis, and that people have been harmed when a counsellor called a medical illness a spiritual failure. They point out that a person can believe scripture is sufficient for faith and life and still need a doctor, just as a believer with a broken leg does. Defenders reply that this describes some of the movement's history, not its convictions; that the second generation has said much of this themselves; that biblical counsellors today generally urge medical assessment and work alongside physicians; and that the alternative to bringing scripture to bear on a troubled heart is not neutrality but quietly accepting another account of what a human being is. Their answer was not to abandon scripture's sufficiency but to apply it with more patience, more listening and more attention to the body.
6. What is settled, what is open, and this week
Between these two movements stand many Christians who call themselves integrationists or Christian psychologists, who hold that scripture is the final authority and that psychological research, read critically, can also inform care. The book Psychology and Christianity: Five Views, edited by Eric Johnson, sets five positions side by side in their own words, from biblical counselling to forms of integration, and is worth finding if you can. This track returns to the question in Module 5, in the lesson on mental illness and faith. Here it is enough to see the shape of the disagreement, and what is not in dispute.
What is settled across the serious traditions is considerable. The care of souls is the church's work and must not be done carelessly. It must be fitted to the person, as scripture and Gregory both teach. Listening before speaking is not optional, and neither is speaking truth when truth is needed. The carer's own heart affects the care. And no pastor, of any school, should handle risk of suicide, the abuse of a child, domestic violence or serious mental illness alone. That is the standard of this whole track, and it is not a concession to psychology; it is what love for the person requires when their life or safety is at stake. What remains genuinely open is how far knowledge from outside scripture is needed in the ordinary care of souls, how directive a carer should be, and how to tell, in a given person, what is sin, what is suffering and what is sickness, when it is often all three at once.
Now add the second page to your care plan. At the top write: What I draw on. First, write one line for each of the teachers in this lesson, Gregory, Bucer, Baxter, the clinical movement and the biblical counselling movement, naming one thing you will take from each into your own care. You do not have to agree with all of them to learn from all of them. Then copy Bucer's five tasks from section 3 and, beside each, write what your church currently does for that group, and what it could begin to do. Write roles, not names.
Second, write down which tradition has shaped you, and what your own church or denomination teaches about who may hear a confession, anoint the sick, or counsel members. If you do not know, ask a senior pastor in your denomination this month and write down the answer. Then, at the bottom of the page, under a heading Never alone, copy these words: suicide risk, abuse of a child, domestic violence, serious mental illness. Beside each, leave a space. In Module 5 you will fill in exactly whom you will call. For now, if you already know who in your area handles child protection or mental health emergencies, write the service, not a person's name, and add it to the box marked Help beyond me on page one.
Key terms
- Regula PastoralisLatin
- The Pastoral Rule, written by Gregory the Great around 590 for bishops. Its third part teaches that different kinds of people must be admonished differently, since the same word can heal one and harm another. It shaped pastoral care in the Western church for a thousand years.
- noutheteoGreek
- To admonish, warn or instruct with a view to change: to put something into another's mind for their good. Used in Acts 20:31, Romans 15:14, Colossians 1:28 and 1 Thessalonians 5:14. Jay Adams named his nouthetic counselling after it.
- Clinical Pastoral EducationEnglish
- Supervised training in pastoral care through real work in hospitals and similar settings, begun by Anton Boisen and Richard Cabot in the 1920s. Students write up actual conversations, often word for word as a verbatim, and examine them with a supervisor and peers.
Knowledge check
The third part of Gregory the Great's Pastoral Rule sets out pair after pair of different kinds of people. What principle drives that whole section, according to the lesson?