Lesson 1 · 24 min

After the Apostles

The first Christians who wrote after the apostles were bishops, elders, prophets and teachers in Rome, Antioch, Smyrna and the villages of Syria. This lesson introduces Clement, Ignatius, Polycarp and the Didache as real documents with real dates and real disputes, and tells honestly what they show and do not show about how the church was led in the generation after the apostles.

Therefore, brothers, stand firm and cling to the traditions we taught you, whether by speech or by letter.

2 Thessalonians 2:15 · BSB

Before you read

Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.

  1. Observe

    Read 2 Thessalonians 2:15, 1 Corinthians 11:2, 1 Corinthians 11:23, 1 Corinthians 15:3 and 2 Timothy 2:2. For each, write down who hands something on, who receives it, and by what means it travels. Copy the verbs exactly.

  2. Notice

    Read Acts 14:23, Acts 20:17 with 20:28, Philippians 1:1 and Titus 1:5-7. List every title given to church leaders in these verses, and notice whether each title is used in the singular or the plural and whether two titles are ever used of the same people.

  3. Hear it then

    Read 1 Corinthians 1:10-12, 3:3-4 and 11:17-19. Describe in your own words what kind of trouble the church at Corinth was having in Paul's own lifetime, and what it suggests about the kinds of problems a letter written to the same church forty years later might face.

  4. Weigh the words

    On Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, both free, look up the Greek words episkopos (overseer) at Philippians 1:1 and 1 Timothy 3:2, presbyteros (elder) at Titus 1:5 and 1 Peter 5:1, and paradosis (tradition) at 2 Thessalonians 2:15. Write down the range of meanings each tool gives, and where each word is used outside the church in the New Testament.

  5. Why it matters

    Write down the titles your own church uses for its leaders, how a person comes to hold each one, and who, if anyone, oversees more than one congregation. Then write one sentence saying where you think your church's pattern came from. Keep the page; you will test that sentence against this lesson.

1. The generation nobody planned for

The New Testament ends with a church that still has apostles in it, or has only just lost them. The last books were written by men who had known Jesus or had known those who did. Then, within a few decades, every one of them was dead, and the churches they had planted from Syria to Rome had to go on without anyone who could say, I was there. This module begins at that point. Church history in this track does not start with the councils or the emperors. It starts with ordinary congregations asking how to stay faithful to what they had been taught when the teachers had gone.

The writers who answered first are called the Apostolic Fathers. The label is modern. It goes back to a 1672 edition by the French scholar Jean-Baptiste Cotelier of the fathers who flourished in apostolic times, and later editors settled on a conventional collection: the letter known as 1 Clement, a sermon known as 2 Clement, seven letters of Ignatius of Antioch, Polycarp's letter to the Philippians and the account of his martyrdom, the Didache, the Epistle of Barnabas, the Shepherd of Hermas, the Epistle to Diognetus, and fragments of Papias of Hierapolis. They were not written as a set, they do not agree on everything, and some are later than others. What they share is that they come from the century after the apostles and that the church kept reading them.

Notice where they come from, because it sets the map for this whole track. Clement writes from Rome. Ignatius is bishop of Antioch in Syria, the city where the disciples were first called Christians (Acts 11:26). Polycarp is bishop of Smyrna, one of the seven churches of Revelation, on the coast of what is now Turkey. The Didache most likely comes from Syria or perhaps Egypt. Papias is in Phrygia. Barnabas is usually placed in Alexandria. The church of the early second century was a Mediterranean and Near Eastern body, and its centres of gravity were Antioch, Asia Minor, Alexandria and Rome, not northern Europe, where the gospel had barely arrived.

Read these writers with two cautions in hand. First, they are not scripture, and none of them claims to be. Ignatius tells the Romans that he does not give them orders as Peter and Paul did, since they were apostles and he is a condemned man, and Clement writes as a church to a church rather than as an apostle. Second, they are not neutral. Each was written to deal with a problem: a faction, a false teaching, a journey to death. What they tell us about the church's structure and worship comes out sideways, in the course of arguing about something else, and the historian has to read it that way.

For the doctrinal question these documents raise, how the church ought to be governed, Systematic Theology covers the three classic answers and their texts in the lesson Ministry and Mission. This lesson does not repeat that argument. Its question is historical: what do the earliest documents actually show, when were they written, and what do serious historians on different sides make of them.

2. Clement of Rome and the quarrel at Corinth

The letter we call 1 Clement is addressed from the church of God which sojourns at Rome to the church of God which sojourns at Corinth. It does not name its author. The attribution to Clement comes from later witnesses: Dionysius, bishop of Corinth around 170, told the Romans that his church still read Clement's letter aloud on Sundays (Eusebius, Church History 4.23.11), and Irenaeus, writing around 180, names Clement as the third bishop of Rome after Peter and Paul, following Linus and Anacletus, and mentions the letter to Corinth (Against Heresies 3.3.3). The traditional date is about 96, because the opening apologises for delay caused by sudden and repeated misfortunes, which many have read as a reference to trouble under the emperor Domitian. That reading is not certain, and scholars have proposed dates from before 70 to well into the second century; the majority still place it in the last decade of the first century.

The occasion is precise. A group of younger men at Corinth had removed some of the church's elders from office, men the letter says had served blamelessly. Rome writes, at length, to urge the Corinthians to restore order, to repent, and to let the leaders of the faction leave if that is what peace requires. The letter is long, full of Old Testament examples of humility and jealousy, and it remembers Peter and Paul as recent martyrs of Rome. Of Paul it says that he was seven times in chains, preached in the east and the west, and reached the farthest bounds of the west before he died, which is one of the earliest pieces of evidence outside the New Testament for Paul's death.

The passage everyone argues about is in chapters 42 to 44. Clement says that the apostles received the gospel from Christ, preached in country and town, and appointed their first converts, after testing them by the Spirit, as bishops and deacons of those who would believe. Then he says that the apostles knew there would be strife over the office of oversight, and so they appointed these men and afterwards gave instruction that, when they died, other approved men should succeed to their ministry. Those who were appointed in this way, he concludes, cannot rightly be thrown out of their ministry if they have served well. That is the earliest argument in Christian literature for an orderly succession in church leadership.

Two things about it are agreed by almost everyone. The first is that Clement uses bishop and elder for the same people: in chapter 44 the men who were removed are called presbyters, and the office they held is called episkope, oversight. There is no sign of one bishop above a group of elders at Corinth, and the letter itself does not name a single bishop at Rome; it speaks as a church. The second is that Clement does believe the apostles provided for continuity, and that the church's leaders stand in a line that goes back to them. What is disputed is what follows from those two facts, and section 5 sets out the answers.

One more thing is worth noticing for anyone who leads a congregation. The first known letter in the church's history after the New Testament was written to stop a church from throwing out its leaders in a factional dispute, and its main argument is not about power at all. It is about humility, love and order, with long quotations from the Psalms and the prophets. Clement asks the faction to say, if I am the cause of the strife, I will go away wherever you wish. Whatever you conclude about church government, that is a pastoral word every church has needed at one time or another.

3. Ignatius and Polycarp: two bishops of the east

Ignatius was bishop of Antioch in Syria. Under the emperor Trajan, who reigned from 98 to 117, he was arrested and sent under guard of ten soldiers, whom he calls leopards, to be killed by wild beasts in Rome. On the journey across Asia Minor delegations from local churches came to meet him, and he wrote seven letters: to the Ephesians, the Magnesians, the Trallians, the Romans, the Philadelphians, the Smyrnaeans, and to Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna. They are usually dated around 110, though the date depends on a tradition rather than a firm record.

The letters have a complicated history and you should know it, because people still quote the wrong version. They survive in three forms. A long version, with thirteen letters, was expanded in the fourth century. A short Syriac version of three letters was published by William Cureton in 1845. The middle version of seven letters is the one that the great nineteenth-century scholars Theodor Zahn and J. B. Lightfoot defended as authentic, and Lightfoot's Apostolic Fathers, published from 1885, largely settled the question for a century. The settlement has not been unanimous since. Robert Joly argued in 1979 that the letters were a later forgery, and Timothy Barnes argued in 2008 that the genuine letters belong in the 140s rather than around 110. Most specialists still accept the seven and an early second-century date, but if you build an argument on a precise year you are building on a contested foundation.

Three themes run through the letters. The first is a fierce defence of the reality of Christ's flesh against people Ignatius calls docetists, from a Greek word meaning to seem, who taught that Christ only appeared to suffer. He insists that Jesus was truly born, truly persecuted under Pontius Pilate, truly crucified and truly raised, and he says that if Christ only seemed to suffer, then his own chains are meaningless. The second is the Eucharist, which he calls the medicine of immortality (Ephesians 20) and which he ties tightly to the unity of the church. The third is the bishop. Ignatius urges every church to do nothing without the bishop, to gather around one bishop with his council of presbyters and his deacons, and he tells the Trallians that without these three there is not even the name of a church. To the Smyrnaeans he writes that where the bishop appears, there the people should be, just as where Jesus Christ is, there is the catholic church, which is the first surviving use of the phrase catholic church, meaning the whole church.

The letter to the Romans is different. It mentions no bishop at Rome at all, and its purpose is to beg the Roman Christians not to use their influence to save him. He wants to die. He writes that he is God's wheat, to be ground by the teeth of wild beasts so that he may be found pure bread of Christ. Readers have found this either magnificent or disturbing, often both, and it belongs to the next lesson's question of how the early church thought about martyrdom.

Polycarp was bishop of Smyrna, and Irenaeus, who heard him as a boy, says he had been taught by apostles and had talked with John and others who had seen the Lord (Against Heresies 3.3.4; Eusebius, Church History 5.20). His letter to the Philippians survives, a plain, pastoral letter full of echoes of 1 Peter and of Paul, warning against greed and against those who deny that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh. It is worth comparing with Ignatius. Polycarp writes with his presbyters, addresses the Philippians' presbyters and deacons, and mentions no bishop at Philippi. One of their elders, a man named Valens, had fallen into love of money, and Polycarp grieves over him and asks the church to restore him rather than treat him as an enemy. The account of Polycarp's own death, the Martyrdom of Polycarp, is the subject of the next lesson.

Put Ignatius and Polycarp together and you see something important: in Syria and western Asia Minor in the early second century there was a single bishop with presbyters and deacons, and Ignatius treats it as normal rather than new. In Rome and Philippi at about the same time, the evidence does not show it. The pattern was spreading, but it had not yet arrived everywhere at once.

4. The Didache: a church manual from Syria

In 1873 Philotheos Bryennios, a Greek Orthodox metropolitan, was working in the library of the Jerusalem patriarchate's house in Constantinople when he found a manuscript copied in 1056 that contained, among other things, a short work called the Teaching of the Twelve Apostles. He published it in 1883. Its Greek name, Didache, means teaching. Ancient writers had mentioned it, Athanasius among them, who recommended it for new converts, but no one in modern times had read it. Its discovery changed the study of early Christian worship.

The Didache is short, about the length of Galatians, and it reads like a manual for a congregation. Chapters 1 to 6 set out two ways, the way of life and the way of death, drawing on the Sermon on the Mount and on Jewish moral teaching. Chapter 7 gives instructions for baptism. Chapter 8 tells believers to fast on Wednesdays and Fridays rather than on the days the hypocrites fast, and to pray the Lord's Prayer three times a day. Chapters 9 and 10 give prayers for the Eucharist. Chapters 11 to 13 deal with travelling apostles and prophets. Chapter 14 tells the church to gather on the Lord's day, break bread and give thanks, after confessing their sins, and to be reconciled to one another first. Chapter 15 tells them to appoint for themselves bishops and deacons worthy of the Lord. Chapter 16 ends with a warning to watch for the Lord's return. Lesson 6 of this module comes back to its worship.

The chapters on apostles and prophets are among the most practical texts in early Christian literature, and any church that receives visiting preachers can learn from them. A travelling apostle may stay a day, two if necessary; if he stays three, he is a false prophet. If he leaves, he may take bread for the road but not money; if he asks for money, he is a false prophet. Not everyone who speaks in the Spirit is a prophet, but only one who has the ways of the Lord. Then chapter 15 adds that the bishops and deacons also carry out the ministry of the prophets and teachers, and must not be despised. You can see a church in transition: charismatic travelling ministers are still present and honoured, but tested, and settled local leaders are being appointed and their standing defended.

When was it written? Here the experts divide widely. Jean-Paul Audet, in a major commentary of 1958, argued for a date between 50 and 70, which would make parts of it as early as some of Paul's letters, and Aaron Milavec has more recently defended a similarly early date. Kurt Niederwimmer, in the standard German commentary, dated its final form to around 110 to 120, drawing on earlier sources. Many now think it grew in layers, so that the question has more than one answer. The church order is simple: bishops and deacons, with no single bishop above them and no mention of presbyters at all. That is consistent with either an early date or a rural setting where the pattern Ignatius knew had not yet taken hold, and it is wise not to lean too hard on either.

One small phrase in chapter 9 shows how early Christian prayer sounded. The Eucharistic prayer gives thanks for the holy vine of David made known through Jesus, and asks that as broken bread once scattered on the hills was gathered and became one, so the church may be gathered from the ends of the earth into God's kingdom. This is a church that thinks of itself as scattered and as one, and that prays for its unity every time it breaks bread.

5. Bishops and elders: what the evidence shows and how it is read

Lay the evidence out plainly, because the facts are less disputed than their meaning. In the New Testament, elder and overseer are used of the same people, and churches have several of them. In 1 Clement, around 96, bishop and presbyter are still interchangeable, and the Roman church speaks collectively. In the Didache, bishops and deacons are appointed locally. In the Shepherd of Hermas, from Rome in the first half of the second century, the church is led by the elders who preside over it. Polycarp's letter to Philippi addresses presbyters and deacons. But in Ignatius, in Syria and Asia Minor, a single bishop presides over presbyters and deacons, and by the time of Irenaeus, around 180, a single bishop leads each church across the Christian world, and Irenaeus can list the bishops of Rome back to the apostles. Within about eighty years of the New Testament, the pattern of one bishop, many presbyters and deacons was everywhere.

The Catholic and Orthodox reading is that this development is the apostles' own provision working itself out under the Spirit's guidance. Clement already says the apostles provided for succession. Ignatius, who was bishop of Antioch within living memory of the apostles, does not argue for the threefold ministry but assumes it, which suggests it was not new to his readers. Irenaeus appeals to lists of bishops as public evidence that the churches had kept the apostles' teaching, against teachers who claimed secret traditions. On this view, a development that spread to every church within a few generations, and was kept everywhere for fourteen centuries, is the shape the Spirit gave the church, not a departure from it. The Jesuit historian Francis Sullivan, in From Apostles to Bishops (2001), accepted that the single bishop emerged gradually, and in Rome probably not before the middle of the second century, and argued that this is fully compatible with Catholic teaching that bishops succeed the apostles by divine institution, because a Spirit-guided development is still divine. Orthodox theologians add a distinctive emphasis. John Zizioulas, in Eucharist, Bishop, Church, argued that for Ignatius the bishop is first of all the one who presides at the single Eucharist of the local church, so that the office grows out of worship and unity rather than administration.

The Protestant readings start from the same evidence and weigh it differently. They note that the New Testament itself uses elder and overseer interchangeably, that Clement does too, and that the single bishop appears clearly only in the second century and in some places later than others. They point out that Jerome, in the fourth century, said the same: that originally presbyters and bishops were the same, and that one was later set over the rest as a remedy for division. Presbyterians conclude that government by a body of elders is the apostolic pattern and the single bishop a human arrangement, perhaps wise, but not binding. Congregationalists and Baptists add that the Didache has the congregation itself appointing its leaders. The German historian Peter Lampe, in a detailed study of the Roman Christians in the first two centuries, argued that Rome was a network of house churches led by a group of presbyters until about the middle of the second century, which would mean that the later list of Roman bishops reads a single office back into an earlier time. Anglicans and Lutherans who keep bishops often take a middle line: episcopacy is ancient and good for the church's wellbeing, but they do not make it a condition of being a church.

Each reading has a question it finds hard. The Catholic and Orthodox readings must explain why the earliest documents, including Clement's own letter, show no single bishop in Corinth or Rome, and why the lists of Roman bishops are clearest when they are latest. The Protestant readings must explain how a pattern they think unapostolic spread to every church in every region within a few generations, with no record of protest, at a time when the churches were in close contact and quick to condemn innovations. Those are the real questions. A student who can state both without caricature understands the second century better than many who hold a strong view.

Three things can be said as settled. The earliest generations after the apostles cared intensely about continuity with what the apostles taught, and saw their leaders as guardians of it, which is the instinct of 2 Thessalonians 2:15. They used the same handful of offices, elders or bishops, and deacons, everywhere, and treated travelling prophets with honour and caution together. And the arrangement developed over time, at different speeds in different places, so that any church today that claims to have the exact pattern of the year 100 should be asked which city's pattern it means.

6. This week: begin your church's story

This track ends with a capstone: you will write the history of your own congregation or denomination, tracing its roots back through the story these lessons tell. Every lesson adds one page. Start now. Get a notebook, or a section of one, and title it with the name of your church. Write the date you began.

Take the page you wrote in the inquiry, where you listed your church's leaders, how they are appointed and who oversees whom. Under it, write which of the patterns in this lesson your church most resembles: the plural elders of Philippians 1:1 and 1 Clement, the single bishop with presbyters and deacons of Ignatius, the locally appointed bishops and deacons of the Didache, or some combination. Then add one line saying when your church's present pattern began, if you know, and leave a blank line if you do not.

Then find out what you do not know. Ask one older leader in your church, by role, a pastor, an elder, a bishop or a long-serving member, three questions: how did our church come to be led the way it is, who first planted this congregation and from where did they come, and what document, if any, sets out our church order. Write down the answers in your own words with the date. Do not record the name of the person you asked; note only their role. If your church meets in a place where its existence or its leaders could be endangered by what you write, keep the notebook somewhere safe, use no names of living people at all, and write nothing that would identify a meeting place.

Finally, read 2 Thessalonians 2:15 again and write one sentence on what your church has received and clings to, whether by speech or by letter. You will add to this page all through the track. By the end you should be able to tell the story of how what Paul taught at Thessalonica reached the people who sit in your church on Sunday.

Key terms

episkoposGreek
Overseer, the word that became bishop. In the New Testament and in 1 Clement it is used of the same people as presbyteros, elder. By the time of Ignatius in Syria and Asia Minor it names a single leader presiding over a council of presbyters and the deacons, and by the late second century that pattern is found everywhere.
paradosisGreek
Tradition, literally something handed over. Paul uses it of the teaching he passed on (2 Thessalonians 2:15), and Jesus uses the same word of human traditions that set aside God's command (Mark 7:8-9). The word itself is neutral; what matters is whether the thing handed on is the apostles' teaching.
Apostolic FathersEnglish
The conventional name for the earliest Christian writings after the New Testament, including 1 Clement, the letters of Ignatius and Polycarp, the Didache, Barnabas and the Shepherd of Hermas. The label goes back to Cotelier's 1672 edition. They are not scripture, but they are the first witnesses to how the churches lived after the apostles died.
Push on this with the AI Theology Tutor. It already knows what this lesson argued.

Knowledge check

According to the lesson, what does 1 Clement show about church leadership at Corinth and Rome in the 90s?