Lesson 3 · 25 min
Heresy and the Rule of Faith
In the second century the church faced teachers who offered a secret knowledge, a different God, or a new prophecy. This lesson tells who the Gnostic teachers, Marcion and the Montanists actually were, how Irenaeus answered them with the rule of faith, and how historians since Walter Bauer have argued over whether orthodoxy came first or was simply the side that won.
O Timothy, guard what has been entrusted to you. Avoid irreverent, empty chatter and the opposing arguments of so-called "knowledge,"
1 Timothy 6:20 · BSB
Before you read
Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.
Observe
Read 1 Timothy 6:20-21, Colossians 2:8, 2:18 and 2:23, and 1 John 4:1-3. List each thing these writers warn against, in their own words, and what each one tells the readers to hold on to instead.
Notice
Read 1 Corinthians 15:3-5 and 1 Timothy 3:16, two compressed summaries of the faith. Notice what kind of statements they are: about ideas, about events, or about persons. Then write down what someone who taught that the true God never had a body would have to do with each line.
Hear it then
Read 1 Timothy 4:1-5 and 2 Timothy 2:16-18. Describe the two errors these passages name, and explain what each would mean for how a believer treats food, marriage and the body.
Weigh the words
Look up three Greek words on Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible: gnosis (knowledge) at 1 Timothy 6:20 and 1 Corinthians 8:1, hairesis at Acts 5:17, Acts 24:5 and 1 Corinthians 11:19, and paratheke (what has been entrusted) at 1 Timothy 6:20. Write down how each word is used and what it would have meant to an ordinary reader.
Show the evidence
Someone tells you that the earliest Christians had no shared beliefs at all, and that orthodoxy was invented in the fourth century by bishops with imperial power. Gather evidence for and against this claim from Galatians 1:6-9, 1 Corinthians 15:11, Jude 3, and the variety of teachers named in 1 and 2 Timothy, before you read the lesson.
Why it matters
Find your church's statement of faith, or the creed it uses, or, if it has neither, write down the six most important things your church teaches. Then mark any line that seems to have been written to rule something out. Keep the page for the end of the lesson.
1. Choosing for yourself: what heresy meant
The word heresy comes from the Greek hairesis, a choice, and in ordinary speech it meant a school of thought or party. Josephus uses it of the Pharisees, Sadducees and Essenes, and Acts uses it of the same parties and of the Christians themselves. By the second century Christian writers were using it for something else: a teaching chosen for oneself against the faith the churches had received. The shift matters. A heresy in this sense is not simply a mistake, which any believer may make, but a rival account of the gospel, held and taught in a way that divides the church.
This lesson is about the second century, when the church first had to decide, at scale, what counted as its faith and who could teach it. The main rivals were three. Teachers usually grouped together as Gnostics offered a hidden knowledge that would free the spirit from the world. Marcion offered a different God, a purified scripture and a church of his own. The New Prophecy, which opponents called Montanism, offered fresh revelation through prophets. Each forced the church to say something it had not yet had to say so clearly. The Apologetics track deals with modern movements and how to answer them, in the lesson False Teaching and New Religions, and Systematic Theology treats the doctrines at stake. Here the question is historical: who these people were, what they taught, and how the church answered.
One caution before we start. For most of history we knew these teachers mainly through their opponents: Irenaeus, Tertullian, Hippolytus, Epiphanius. Hostile witnesses can be accurate, but they select and they simplify. In December 1945 farmers near Nag Hammadi in Upper Egypt found a jar containing thirteen leather-bound codices, with some fifty texts in Coptic, copied in the fourth century, many of them writings of the kind Irenaeus attacked, among them the Gospel of Truth, the Apocryphon of John and the Gospel of Thomas. For the first time historians could read many of these teachers in their own words. The finds both confirmed some of what the church fathers said and complicated it.
2. Gnostics, Marcion and the New Prophecy
Gnosticism is a modern label for a wide family of teachings, and some scholars, notably Michael Williams in Rethinking Gnosticism (1996) and Karen King in What Is Gnosticism? (2003), have argued that the label groups together too many different things and should be dropped or used with great care. Others, such as David Brakke in The Gnostics (2010), argue that at least one group did call itself the Gnostics and can be described. Most of the systems shared certain features. The material world was made not by the highest God but by a lesser, ignorant or hostile maker, often identified with the God of the Old Testament. Some human beings carry a spark of the divine trapped in matter. Salvation comes by knowledge, gnosis, of where you came from and where you are going, brought by a revealer from the true God. And since flesh is a prison, the Christ who brought this knowledge did not truly take flesh or truly suffer. The best-known teachers were Basilides in Alexandria in the 120s and 130s, and Valentinus, an Egyptian Christian who taught in Rome from about 136 to 160, was a brilliant and respected figure there, and according to Tertullian hoped to become bishop.
Marcion is described in the canon lessons of the Hermeneutics and New Testament Survey tracks, and you should read those for his Bible. Here is his church. He was a shipowner from Sinope on the Black Sea who came to Rome around 140, gave the church a large gift of money, and in 144 was expelled, and the money returned. He taught that the God of the Old Testament, the creator and judge of the law, was a different and lower being than the good Father revealed by Jesus, and his book Antitheses set Old Testament passages against Christian ones to prove it. He was a gifted organiser. Marcionite churches, with their own bishops, worship and martyrs, spread across the empire and survived longest in Syria, where in the fifth century Theodoret, bishop of Cyrrhus, still reported bringing whole villages of Marcionites back to the main church. Irenaeus records that when Marcion once met Polycarp and asked whether he recognised him, the old bishop answered that he recognised the firstborn of Satan.
The New Prophecy began in Phrygia, in the interior of Asia Minor, in the 150s or 170s; ancient sources disagree. Montanus and two women, Priscilla and Maximilla, prophesied in ecstasy, speaking in the first person as the Spirit, and announced that the heavenly Jerusalem would descend at the Phrygian village of Pepuza. Their followers fasted more, forbade second marriage, and welcomed martyrdom. Unlike the Gnostics and Marcion, they did not change the doctrine of God or of Christ; the dispute was over whether new revelation could add to the church's discipline, and whether prophecy in a frenzy was a mark of the Spirit or its opposite. Bishops in Asia met repeatedly to examine the movement, and these are among the earliest church synods on record. Tertullian of Carthage joined the movement around 207, which shows it attracted serious people.
Montanism deserves a fair hearing, because it has been read in very different ways. Most of the ancient church judged that it confused excitement with the Spirit and claimed an authority over scripture and the bishops that no prophet could have. But John Wesley, late in his life, wrote a short piece called The Real Character of Montanus, arguing that Montanus was a good and holy man misrepresented by his enemies, and some historians, and some Pentecostal and charismatic writers, have argued that the church's reaction went too far and pushed prophecy itself to the margins of church life. Others reply that the church never denied the gifts of the Spirit, as Irenaeus himself testifies that they continued in his day, but tested prophets as the Didache and 1 John 4:1 told it to. Hold that question open: it returns in the Pentecostal lesson of Module 5.
3. Irenaeus and the rule of faith
The great answer to the Gnostic teachers came from a bishop on the edge of the empire. Irenaeus was born in Smyrna, probably in the 130s, and as a boy heard Polycarp preach, as he told a friend years later (Eusebius, Church History 5.20). He moved to Lyons in Gaul, a Greek-speaking Christian among Celtic and Latin neighbours, and was a presbyter there during the persecution of 177, when he carried a letter to Rome. When he returned, the aged bishop Pothinus was dead, and Irenaeus succeeded him. Around 180 he wrote five books with a title taken straight from this lesson's anchor: A Refutation and Overthrow of Knowledge Falsely So Called, usually called Against Heresies. A shorter work, the Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching, was lost for centuries and found in 1904 in an Armenian translation, a reminder of how much of the early church's memory was kept outside the Latin and Greek world.
Irenaeus made four moves that shaped all later Christian thinking. First, he described the Gnostic systems in detail and showed that they disagreed with each other, which he took as a sign that they were human inventions. Second, he argued that the true tradition was public, not secret: if the apostles had known hidden mysteries, they would have taught them to the men they made leaders of the churches, and those churches, whose succession of bishops could be named, teach no such thing. Third, he insisted that scripture must be read as a whole and according to its own shape. He compared the Gnostics to someone who takes a beautiful mosaic of a king, made by a skilled artist, breaks it up, and rearranges the jewels into the figure of a dog or a fox, and then claims it is the king's portrait because the stones are the same (Against Heresies 1.8.1). Fourth, he gave the shape that tells you how the stones go together: the rule of faith.
Irenaeus calls it the rule of truth, in Greek kanon tes aletheias, received at baptism. He sets it out in Against Heresies 1.10.1. The church, scattered through the whole world to the ends of the earth, has received from the apostles and their disciples faith in one God, the Father Almighty, maker of heaven and earth and the sea and all that is in them; and in one Christ Jesus, the Son of God, made flesh for our salvation; and in the Holy Spirit, who proclaimed through the prophets the saving plan of God, including Christ's birth from a virgin, his passion, his resurrection from the dead, his bodily ascension, and his coming from heaven in the glory of the Father to raise all flesh and to judge. Then he says (1.10.2) that the church, though scattered, keeps this faith carefully as if it lived in one house, and that the churches in Germany, in Spain, among the Celts, in the east, in Egypt and in Libya do not believe or hand down anything different.
Notice what the rule of faith is and is not. It is not a fixed wording; Irenaeus and Tertullian give it in slightly different forms in different places. It is not a substitute for scripture; it is a summary of scripture's storyline, the hypothesis or plot of the whole Bible, by which a reader can tell whether the jewels have been arranged into a king or a fox. It always runs in three parts, Father, Son and Spirit, because it grew out of the baptismal confession of Matthew 28:19. And every clause aimed at the rivals: one God, who is also the maker of the world, against both Gnostics and Marcion; a Son who truly became flesh, against the docetists; a Spirit who spoke in the prophets, so the Old Testament belongs to the same God. Tertullian, around 200, used the same tool in his Prescription against Heretics, arguing that heretics had no right to argue from scripture at all because scripture belonged to the churches that had received it from the apostles. It is in that work, chapter 7, that he asked, in the Ante-Nicene Fathers wording, "What indeed has Athens to do with Jerusalem?"
From the rule of faith came the creeds. At baptism candidates were asked three questions, whether they believed in God the Father, in Christ Jesus, and in the Holy Spirit, and answered I believe to each. Over time these questions were turned into statements. The Old Roman Creed is first quoted in full by Marcellus of Ancyra in a letter of around 340 and by Rufinus around 404, and the Apostles' Creed in its final Western form appears in the eighth century. The Nicene Creed, which grew from Eastern baptismal creeds, is the subject of the next module. The creeds the church still uses are the rule of faith set into fixed words, and every line is a fence put up where someone once tried to move the boundary.
4. Walter Bauer: did heresy come first?
In 1934 the German scholar Walter Bauer published Orthodoxy and Heresy in Earliest Christianity, translated into English in 1971. He argued that the traditional story, in which the apostles taught orthodoxy and heretics later departed from it, is backwards in many regions. In Edessa in Syria, he argued, the earliest Christians we can identify were followers of Marcion and of the Syrian teacher Bardaisan, and the group later called orthodox was a latecomer known by the name of a bishop, Palut. In Egypt, the near silence of the sources about Christianity before about 180 suggested to him that the earliest Egyptian Christians were of the kind later called Gnostic, and that this is why later orthodox writers did not care to remember them. Across the second century, he argued, the Roman church, organised, wealthy and well connected, steadily imposed its version on others, beginning with 1 Clement's intervention at Corinth. Orthodoxy, on this view, is the name the winning side gave itself.
The thesis was enormously influential, especially in the English-speaking world after the translation, and later scholars developed it. Helmut Koester and James Robinson, in Trajectories through Early Christianity (1971), spoke of many lines of early Christianity developing side by side. Elaine Pagels's The Gnostic Gospels (1979) brought the Nag Hammadi texts to a wide public as evidence of suppressed alternatives. Bart Ehrman's Lost Christianities (2003) presented the second century as a contest among many Christianities in which one side won and rewrote the history. The strongest form of this case is not that all early Christians were heretics but that the categories orthodox and heretic were drawn up after the contest and then projected back, and that the losing sides had better claims to be early and Christian than the winners admitted. Those who hold it point, rightly, to the real variety visible in the sources and to the fact that history is usually written by those who prevail.
The critics have been many and their objections are substantial. H. E. W. Turner, in the Bampton Lectures published as The Pattern of Christian Truth (1954), argued that early Christianity had fixed elements, the central convictions about God, Christ and salvation, and flexible elements in how these were expressed, and that the fixed elements were present early everywhere. C. H. Roberts's study of the earliest Christian papyri from Egypt, Manuscript, Society and Belief in Early Christian Egypt (1979), found that the earliest surviving Christian manuscripts there are overwhelmingly of books the mainstream church used, which weakened Bauer's case at what he had thought its strongest point. Thomas Robinson's The Bauer Thesis Examined (1988) argued that in western Asia Minor, where the evidence is fullest, Bauer's thesis fails, and that a theory unable to account for the best-documented region is not reliable for the poorly documented ones. Others pointed to the argument from silence in Egypt, and to the New Testament itself, which already distinguishes the gospel from its distortions in the first generation. More recently, Andreas Köstenberger and Michael Kruger restated many of these objections at a popular level in The Heresy of Orthodoxy (2010). Defenders of a modified Bauer view reply that the surviving evidence was itself chosen and copied by the side that won, so that its silence about rivals proves less than the critics claim, and that showing orthodoxy was early in Asia Minor does not show it was early everywhere.
Where does the debate stand? The Systematic Theology lesson Faith Seeking Understanding gives the short summary, and it is fair: Bauer's strong thesis, that heresy was generally prior and orthodoxy a Roman imposition, has been rejected by most specialists, while his insistence on real early diversity has been absorbed by nearly everyone. Rowan Williams, in an essay of 1989 asking whether it makes sense to speak of pre-Nicene orthodoxy, gave one of the most careful answers: before Nicaea there was no fixed orthodox system, but there was a recognisable shared sense of what the Christian story is and a process of testing new proposals against it, so orthodoxy was something the church was doing rather than a finished thing it possessed. That allows both sides their best point. The church was diverse and argued from the start, and the rule of faith was not invented by the winners but was already the touchstone by which second-century Christians in Lyons, Carthage, Smyrna and Rome tested what they heard.
5. Why this history matters to a congregation
The second-century crisis was not a contest between clever teachers and simple believers. Valentinus was a profound thinker and a fine writer, Marcion a talented organiser, Montanus and his prophets people of evident devotion. What they offered was attractive: an inner elite of the truly spiritual, a God without the hard edges of the Old Testament, a church purer and more intense than the ordinary one. The church's answer was not mainly to out-argue them, though it did that. It was to say: the faith is public, it is the same in Lyons and in Libya, it is the story the whole scripture tells, and it was handed to the whole church, not to a few.
That answer has a cost, and it is honest to name it. The rule of faith gave bishops a strong tool, and the appeal to succession could be used, and later was used, to silence questions that should have been heard. Those who think Bauer saw something real are right to warn that a church can call its own preferences the faith once delivered. Those who think the rule of faith was the apostles' own legacy are right that without some shared account of the story the church becomes a set of private religions with a common name. Every congregation lives between those two dangers.
Something can be said as settled. The early church did not decide what was Christian by vote or by force in the second century; it had no state power. It decided by appeal to the scriptures, read whole, and to the public teaching the churches had in common, and it was willing to separate from attractive teachers when they denied that the one God made the world, that Christ truly came in the flesh, and that the Spirit who spoke in the prophets is the same Spirit given to the church. Those convictions are still the dividing line between the Christian faith and the alternatives that have always grown up beside it.
6. This week: your church's rule of faith
Add page three to your church history notebook and head it What we believe and why. Copy out your church's statement of faith, or the creed it uses, or the six things you wrote down in the inquiry. Then go through it line by line and, next to each line, write which of the second-century disputes it would have answered, if any: one God who is also the creator, against the Gnostics and Marcion; Christ truly human and truly divine, against the docetists; the Old Testament as the word of the same God, against Marcion; scripture as complete and the test of all prophecy, against the New Prophecy. Some lines will answer later disputes, about the Trinity, the sacraments, justification or the last things. Mark those with a question mark; later lessons will help you fill them in.
Then find out where your church's statement came from. Did your denomination write it, adopt an older confession, or simply use the Apostles' or Nicene Creed? When was it adopted, and why? If your congregation has no written statement, write one sentence on what holds its teaching together, and who decides when someone is teaching something wrong. Ask a leader in your church, by role, how a new teacher or visiting preacher is tested before being allowed to teach. Compare the answer with the Didache's tests from Lesson 1 and with 1 John 4:1-3.
Finally, write two sentences on 1 Timothy 6:20 in your own words: what has your church been entrusted with, and what is the so-called knowledge it most needs to avoid in your place and time? Be specific and fair. The point is not to find enemies but to know what you are guarding.
Key terms
- hairesisGreek
- A choice, then a school or party: used in Acts of the Sadducees, the Pharisees and the Christians. By the second century Christian writers used it for a teaching chosen against the faith the churches had received, which gave English the word heresy.
- regula fideiLatin
- The rule of faith, called by Irenaeus in Greek the canon of truth. A summary of the storyline of scripture in three parts, Father, Son and Spirit, received at baptism and used to test teaching. It had no single fixed wording, and from it grew the baptismal creeds.
- gnosisGreek
- Knowledge. An ordinary New Testament word, used positively and negatively; at 1 Timothy 6:20 Paul warns against what is falsely called knowledge. The second-century teachers usually called Gnostics taught that salvation comes through a hidden knowledge of the spirit's origin and destiny.
Knowledge check
How does the lesson describe Irenaeus's rule of faith and the job it did?