Lesson 6 · 25 min
Worship in the Early Church
What actually happened when the first Christians met: before dawn in Bithynia, in a house church on the Euphrates, in Justin's Rome. This lesson reads the earliest sources on baptism and the long preparation for it, the Eucharist, the Lord's day and the church's songs, weighs the debates over infant baptism and the Sabbath fairly, and explains why a famous church order once credited to Hippolytus is now argued over.
They devoted themselves to the apostles' teaching and to the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and to prayer.
Acts 2:42 · BSB
Before you read
Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.
Observe
Read Acts 2:41-47. Write down every activity the first believers did together, how often they did it, where, and with what attitude. Separate the four things listed in verse 42 from the rest.
Notice
Read Luke 24:30-35, John 20:19 and 20:26, Acts 20:7 and 1 Corinthians 16:2. Notice which day each passage mentions and what happens on it. What pattern do you see, and how strongly does the text itself state it?
Hear it then
Read 1 Corinthians 11:17-34 and 14:26-33. Describe what the gatherings at Corinth looked like: what was eaten, who took part, what went wrong, and what Paul tells them to change.
Weigh the words
On Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, look up three Greek words: eucharisteo (to give thanks) at Luke 22:19 and 1 Corinthians 11:24, koinonia (fellowship, participation) at Acts 2:42 and 1 Corinthians 10:16, and baptizo at Mark 7:4 and Acts 8:38. Write down the range of meanings for each and what each suggests about early worship.
Show the evidence
Someone tells you that the New Testament clearly settles whether infants of believers should be baptised. Gather what Acts 2:38-39, Acts 16:15, Acts 16:33, 1 Corinthians 1:16 and Mark 16:16 contribute to the question, and state what each verse can and cannot show.
Why it matters
Write down the order of your church's main weekly service from beginning to end, in as much detail as you can remember: every song, prayer, reading, sermon, offering, meal or sacrament. Keep the page; you will compare it with the earliest Christian services.
1. The sources, and how to read them
Worship is where the early church can be seen most clearly, because every congregation did it every week, and it is also where the evidence is most scattered. There is no complete early order of service. There are a few precious descriptions, each written for another purpose: a church manual from Syria, a Roman governor's report, a philosopher's defence of his faith addressed to an emperor, a pilgrim woman's travel diary, the remains of a house on the Euphrates. Read them together and a picture appears, but it is a mosaic with gaps, and different traditions fill the gaps differently. The doctrines of baptism and the Lord's Supper, and what Christians disagree about in them, are treated in Systematic Theology in the lesson The Sacraments. This lesson tells what the early churches did.
The earliest outside witness is Pliny, the Roman governor of Bithynia, writing to the emperor Trajan around 112 (Letters 10.96). Questioning Christians, some under torture, he learned that they met on a fixed day before dawn and sang a hymn to Christ as to a god, alternately among themselves, and bound themselves by an oath, not to any crime, but not to commit theft, robbery or adultery, nor break their word. Then they separated and met again later to take food, ordinary and harmless food, he stresses, and they had stopped even this after his edict banning private associations. To find out more he tortured two slave women whom the Christians called ministrae, a Latin word that may translate the Greek for deacons. He found nothing but, in his words, a depraved and excessive superstition. Notice what an outsider saw: an early morning gathering, singing to Christ as divine, a moral commitment, and a shared meal, conducted by people who included slaves in recognised roles.
The Didache, from Syria and probably from the late first or early second century, as Lesson 1 told, gives the earliest instructions from inside a church. Justin Martyr, a philosopher from Samaria who taught in Rome and was beheaded there around 165, gives in his First Apology, chapters 61 to 67, written around 150 to 155, the fullest early description of baptism and the Sunday Eucharist. And at Dura-Europos, a Roman frontier town on the Euphrates in modern Syria, archaeologists in the 1930s uncovered an ordinary house that had been converted into a church around 232 and was buried in 256 when the town was strengthened against a Persian siege. It had a meeting room for perhaps sixty or seventy people and a baptistery with a basin under an arch, its walls painted with the Good Shepherd, the healing of the paralytic, Christ and Peter walking on the water and women coming to the tomb. It is one of the oldest identified church buildings in the world, and its paintings are now at Yale. It is in Syria, not Rome.
2. Becoming a Christian: baptism and the catechumenate
In Acts people are often baptised on the day they believe, as the Ethiopian official was in the last lesson. Within a century the church had begun to prepare people more carefully, and by the third century preparation could take years. The Didache tells those who baptise to teach the two ways first, then to baptise in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit in living, that is running, water; if there is no running water, in other water; if not cold, then warm; and if neither is available, to pour water three times on the head in the threefold name. The one baptising, the one being baptised, and any others who can, should fast beforehand. Even this earliest manual allows for flexibility in mode while insisting on the Trinitarian name.
Justin describes baptism in Rome around 150. Those who are persuaded that what the church teaches is true, and undertake to live by it, are taught to pray and fast for the forgiveness of their sins, with the church praying and fasting with them, and are then brought to where there is water and washed in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. He says this washing is called illumination, because those who learn these things are enlightened. Then the newly baptised person is brought to the assembly, where the brothers are gathered, for common prayers, the kiss of peace and the Eucharist.
By the third and fourth centuries the period of preparation, the catechumenate, had become a formal stage of church life. Catechumens, from a Greek word for those being instructed, attended the first part of the service, the readings and sermon, and were dismissed before the Eucharist. Their lives were examined, their occupations sometimes questioned, and in the final weeks before Easter they received intensive teaching. Cyril of Jerusalem's Catechetical Lectures, from around 350, preserve the teaching given in Lent to candidates there, and a further set of lectures explaining the sacraments to the newly baptised in Easter week, whose attribution to Cyril or to his successor is debated. The pilgrim Egeria, a woman probably from Spain or Gaul who travelled in the east around 381 to 384, left a diary describing how in Jerusalem the bishop taught the candidates for three hours a day through Lent, going through the whole of scripture and then the creed, while their sponsors and the faithful listened, and how the people applauded when he explained the mysteries after Easter. Baptism itself was usually at Easter, at night, followed by first communion at dawn.
Did the early church baptise infants? This is the most contested question in the history of early worship, and it is fair to say that the evidence can be read in both directions. Tertullian, around 200, in the first Christian treatise on baptism, advised delaying baptism for little children until they could know Christ, which shows that some were baptising them. Origen, in the third century, said the church had received from the apostles the tradition of baptising infants. Cyprian and a council of sixty-six African bishops, around 253, answered a bishop named Fidus, who thought infants should wait until the eighth day like circumcision, by saying that they should not be kept from baptism even that long. In 1958 the German scholar Joachim Jeremias argued that infant baptism was the practice from the apostolic households onward; Kurt Aland replied in 1961 that there is no clear evidence for it before the late second century, and the two exchanged further books. More recently Everett Ferguson, in his massive Baptism in the Early Church (2009), argued that believers' baptism was the norm in the first two centuries and that infant baptism spread from the emergency baptism of dying children. Those who baptise infants answer that the household texts, the continuity with circumcision and the absence of any record of protest against an innovation point the other way. Both readings are held by serious historians, and the question is not one this lesson can close.
3. The Lord's day and the Eucharist
Here is the centre of Justin's account, from his First Apology, chapter 67, in the Ante-Nicene Fathers translation: "And on the day called Sunday, all who live in cities or in the country gather together to one place, and the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits; then, when the reader has ceased, the president verbally instructs, and exhorts to the imitation of these good things." Then, he goes on, they all rise together and pray; bread and wine mixed with water are brought; the president offers prayers and thanksgivings according to his ability, and the people give their assent by saying Amen; each receives a share, and the deacons carry a portion to those who are absent. Those who are well off give what each thinks fit, and what is collected is deposited with the president, who uses it to help orphans and widows, the sick, those in prison and strangers. They meet on Sunday, Justin explains, because it is the first day, on which God made the world, and on which Jesus Christ rose from the dead.
Look at the shape: readings from apostles and prophets as long as time allows, a sermon applying them, common prayer, the bringing of bread and wine, a long prayer of thanksgiving, the people's Amen, communion, communion carried to the absent, and a collection for the poor. Almost every Christian service on earth today, Orthodox, Catholic, Anglican, Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist, Baptist or Pentecostal, can be traced to this outline, though different traditions have kept different parts of it more fully. Notice too what is absent: no fixed prayer text, since the president prays according to his ability, and no separate building.
What did they believe was happening at the table? The Didache's prayers give thanks over cup and bread for the life and knowledge made known through Jesus and pray for the church to be gathered into God's kingdom, and say that no one should eat or drink unless baptised, since the Lord said not to give what is holy to dogs. Ignatius called the bread the medicine of immortality. Justin writes, in the same translation, that "not as common bread and common drink do we receive these", but that the food over which thanks has been given is the flesh and blood of the incarnate Jesus. Catholic and Orthodox readers see in these texts an early witness to a real change or real presence; Lutherans see Christ's true body and blood given with the bread; many Reformed readers see a real spiritual feeding on Christ described in the strong language of the sacrament; and memorialist readers note that the same writers also speak of remembrance and thanksgiving, and that later technical categories should not be read back into them. The Sacraments lesson in Systematic Theology lays out each position. The historian can say this much without taking sides: the early church spoke of the Eucharist with great reverence and realism, guarded it for the baptised, and celebrated it every Lord's day.
The Lord's day itself is first named at Revelation 1:10. The Didache tells believers to gather on the Lord's own day to break bread, Ignatius writes to the Magnesians of those who were no longer keeping the Sabbath but living according to the Lord's day, and the Epistle of Barnabas calls Sunday the eighth day, the beginning of a new world. On 7 March 321 Constantine made Sunday a day of rest from public business in the empire, which belongs to the next module. Whether Sunday replaced the Sabbath is a real disagreement. Samuele Bacchiocchi, a Seventh-day Adventist who studied at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, argued in From Sabbath to Sunday (1977) that Sunday worship arose in Rome in the second century, partly to distance Christians from Jews, and that the Sabbath command still binds. A group of evangelical scholars edited by D. A. Carson replied in From Sabbath to Lord's Day (1982), arguing that Sunday gatherings go back to the apostolic church and that the Sabbath finds its fulfilment in Christ. Among the ancient churches, the Ethiopian Orthodox Church has long kept both the Saturday Sabbath and the Lord's day. The New Testament evidence for first-day gatherings is real, and no verse commands the change; both sides should be able to say both.
4. Singing: from Pliny's hymn to Ephrem's choirs
Colossians 3:16 tells believers to sing 'psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs with gratitude in your hearts to God,' and the early church sang from the beginning. Pliny's informants told him they sang to Christ as to a god. Very little of the music survives, but some of the words do. The Odes of Solomon, a collection of Syriac hymns probably from the second century, are among the earliest Christian hymnbooks outside the Bible. The evening hymn known by its Greek opening words, Phos Hilaron, O gladsome light, was already old when Basil of Caesarea quoted it in the fourth century as a song whose author nobody remembered, and it is still sung at Orthodox evening prayer, which makes it probably the oldest Christian hymn outside scripture in continuous use. A papyrus from Oxyrhynchus in Egypt, from the late third century, preserves a fragment of a Christian hymn to the Trinity with its musical notation, the oldest written Christian music known.
The great hymn writer of the early church wrote in Syriac. Ephrem, born around 306 at Nisibis on the border of Rome and Persia, moved to Edessa in 363 when Nisibis was handed to the Persians, and died there in 373. He wrote hundreds of hymns, called madrashe, full of rich biblical imagery, on Christ's birth, the church, paradise and faith, and he is remembered in the Syriac tradition as the harp of the Spirit. A later Syriac writer, Jacob of Serugh, says that Ephrem trained choirs of women to sing his hymns in church, partly to counter the popular hymns of Bardaisan's followers. Here, as in the Missions track's lesson on the Church of the East, the Syriac churches show a Christianity that was neither Greek nor Latin and that taught doctrine to whole congregations by teaching them to sing it.
In the Latin West, Ambrose of Milan wrote hymns in a simple, memorable metre that is still in use. Augustine records in his Confessions (9.7) that in 386, when Ambrose and his congregation occupied a church to keep it from being handed to the Arians, they began singing hymns and psalms in the eastern manner to keep up their spirits through the long vigil, and that the practice spread from there across the Western church. Then as now, what a church sang shaped what it believed. The Arians had their own songs, and the Nicene churches answered them in kind, a story the next module tells.
5. The Apostolic Tradition: whose, when and where?
For most of the twentieth century one document was treated as the key to early Christian worship: a church order called the Apostolic Tradition, credited to Hippolytus, a presbyter in Rome who wrote in Greek, opposed several bishops of Rome, and died in exile in Sardinia around 235. It gives prayers for ordaining bishops, presbyters and deacons, a full Eucharistic prayer, the rules for the catechumenate, which it says should normally last three years, and a detailed order of baptism with three questions about faith in the Father, Son and Spirit answered at the font. Few texts have had such an influence on modern worship. The Roman Catholic liturgical reforms after the Second Vatican Council based the second Eucharistic Prayer of the 1970 Missal on its Eucharistic prayer, and Anglican, Lutheran and Methodist revisions in the same years drew on it heavily.
The trouble is that its author, date and place are all disputed. No Greek manuscript of the work survives; it was reconstructed from a family of later church orders in Latin, Coptic, Arabic and Ethiopic, the oldest of which was long known as the Egyptian Church Order. In 1910 Eduard Schwartz and in 1916 R. H. Connolly independently argued that this was the lost Apostolic Tradition of Hippolytus, partly because a list of works carved on a statue found in Rome in 1551, and identified as Hippolytus, includes a title about apostolic tradition. Gregory Dix in 1937 and Bernard Botte in 1963 produced the editions that liturgists used for a generation, and the attribution became standard.
From the 1990s it was seriously challenged. Paul Bradshaw, Maxwell Johnson and L. Edward Phillips, in their commentary The Apostolic Tradition (2002), argued that the work is not a single author's text at all but a piece of living literature: a collection of material from different places and times, from perhaps the mid-second to the mid-fourth century, which was revised as it was copied, and which cannot safely be credited to Hippolytus or to Rome. They pointed out that the statue was originally a seated female figure, restored in the sixteenth century, and that the title on its list does not clearly match. Alistair Stewart, in his own translation and commentary, defended a closer link to a Roman community and to the Hippolytan circle, while agreeing that the text grew in layers. Most liturgical scholars now hold some version of the composite view, and some still defend a Roman third-century core.
Why does this matter to a church? Because much of what modern churches did when they reformed their worship in the 1960s and 1970s was justified as a return to the worship of third-century Rome, on the strength of this document. If the text is a composite of uncertain origin, then that justification is weaker than it seemed, even if the prayers themselves are ancient and good. The episode is a warning for anyone who wants to recover the early church: the evidence is fragmentary, and confident reconstructions should be held with an open hand. It is also an encouragement. The core pattern, word and table, baptism after teaching, prayers in the Trinitarian name, care for the poor, does not depend on any one disputed document. It is there in Acts, the Didache, Pliny and Justin, and it is not seriously in doubt.
6. This week: trace your Sunday
Add page six to your church history notebook and head it How we worship. Copy the order of service you wrote in the inquiry. Beside each element, write the earliest source in this lesson where something like it appears: the four things of Acts 2:42, the readings and sermon in Justin, the prayers, the offering for the poor, the Eucharist, baptism and the preparation for it, the songs. Mark anything your church does that has no early parallel, and anything the early church did that your church does not.
Then ask a leader in your church, by role, three questions and write down the answers in your own words. How often does our church celebrate the Lord's Supper, and why that often? How do we prepare people for baptism, and how long does it take? Where did our order of service come from: a denomination's book, a founding missionary, a local tradition, or the leader's own choice? If your church has a written liturgy or a worship book, note its title and date.
Finally, write one paragraph comparing your Sunday with the Sunday Justin described in Rome around 150. What has your church kept, what has it added, and what, if anything, has it lost? This page closes the first module of your church's story. You now have pages on its leaders, its suffering and restoration, its creed, its Bible, its African roots and its worship, each traced back to the first centuries. The next module adds the councils that shaped the creeds your church still confesses.
Key terms
- eucharistiaGreek
- Thanksgiving, from the verb Jesus uses when he gives thanks over the bread (Luke 22:19; 1 Corinthians 11:24). By the time of the Didache and Ignatius it is the name for the Lord's Supper itself, and Justin says the food over which thanks is given is called the Eucharist.
- catechumenEnglish
- From the Greek katechoumenos, one being instructed. A person preparing for baptism, who in the third and fourth centuries attended the readings and sermon, was dismissed before the Eucharist, and received intensive teaching before baptism at Easter.
- Lord's dayEnglish
- Sunday, the first day of the week, named in Revelation 1:10 and in Greek kyriake hemera. The Didache, Ignatius, Barnabas and Justin all speak of Christians gathering on it because Christ rose on the first day. Whether it replaces or sits beside the Sabbath is still debated.
Knowledge check
Why does the lesson say the debate over the Apostolic Tradition matters to churches today?