Lesson 2 · 26 min
Persecution and Martyrdom
From Nero to Diocletian, and beyond the empire in Persia, Christians were arrested, tried and killed for the name of Christ. This lesson tells the story accurately, with its dates and sources, follows the hardest question it left behind, what to do with those who gave way, through the Novatian and Donatist splits, and weighs the modern debate about how widespread the persecution really was.
Do not fear what you are about to suffer. Behold, the devil is about to throw some of you into prison to test you, and you will suffer tribulation for ten days. Be faithful even unto death, and I will give you the crown of life.
Revelation 2:10 · BSB
Before you read
Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.
Observe
Read the letter to the church in Smyrna, Revelation 2:8-11, slowly. List everything the risen Christ says he knows about the church, everything he says will happen to it, and everything he promises. Then note how he introduces himself in verse 8.
Notice
Compare Matthew 10:23 with Revelation 2:10. One tells disciples what to do when persecuted in a town, the other tells a church what to be in prison. Write down what each requires, and describe what a believer would have to weigh to obey both.
Hear it then
Read 1 Peter 4:12-16 and Acts 5:40-41. Describe what these first-century believers were being told about suffering for the name of Christ, and what that suggests about why later Roman officials treated the name itself as the crime.
Weigh the words
On Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, look up the Greek noun martys at Acts 1:8, Acts 22:20 and Revelation 2:13, and the verb thlibo or noun thlipsis (tribulation, affliction) at Revelation 2:9-10. What is the basic meaning of martys, and how does its use shift across these verses?
Show the evidence
Someone tells you that the early church was hunted continuously for three hundred years, everywhere, until Constantine. Using Acts 9:31, Acts 28:30-31 and Revelation 2:13 with 2:10, gather the evidence that persecution was real and the evidence that it varied by time and place, before you read the lesson's account.
Why it matters
Think of a believer you know of, described only by their role, who once denied or abandoned the faith under pressure and later wanted to return. Write down what your church did, or would do, and what you think it should do. Keep the page; this lesson's history is about that exact question.
1. What the empire wanted, and why Christians would not give it
The Missions track has already told part of this story, in the lesson The Persecuted Church: Tacitus on Nero's torches in 64, Pliny's letter to Trajan around 112 and the emperor's reply that Christians were not to be hunted out but punished if accused and unrepentant, and the deaths of Polycarp and Perpetua. Read that section if you have not. This lesson goes further into the sources, follows persecution through to its end in the empire and its beginning in Persia, and spends most of its time on the question persecution left behind for the church itself.
Begin with why it happened at all, because the answer is not obvious. The Roman Empire tolerated hundreds of religions. What it required was that the gods who protected the city and the empire receive their honour, and that subjects show loyalty, often by offering a pinch of incense or a libation before the image of the gods or the emperor. Most people in the empire could do this without difficulty; their gods did not object to other gods. Jews were generally exempted by long custom as an ancient people. Christians were neither: they refused the sacrifice, they were not an ethnic nation with ancestral rites, and they gathered privately and spoke of eating flesh and blood and of loving their brothers and sisters, which outsiders easily heard as cannibalism and incest. When disaster struck, a plague, a flood, a failed harvest, the people who refused the gods were the obvious ones to blame. Tertullian of Carthage mocked this around 197: if the Tiber floods or the Nile does not, the cry goes up, the Christians to the lion.
The historian G. E. M. de Ste. Croix argued in a famous article in 1963, Why Were the Early Christians Persecuted?, that the heart of it was this refusal to honour the gods, which threatened the peace between the gods and the community, rather than any specific crime. That explains a feature of the trials that puzzled Pliny himself. Christians were not usually charged with doing anything; they were asked whether they were Christians, and if they confessed the name and would not sacrifice, they were executed. Christians felt this as an outrage, and their apologists said so. Justin Martyr, writing to the emperor Antoninus Pius around 150, protested that Christians were condemned for a name without any inquiry into their deeds.
For most of the first two hundred and fifty years, then, there was no empire-wide law against Christians. Persecution depended on local governors, local crowds and local accusers. It flared under Nero in Rome in 64, possibly under Domitian in the 90s, though the evidence for a general persecution then is thin, in Bithynia under Pliny, in Smyrna under the proconsul who tried Polycarp, and in Gaul in 177, when the churches of Lyons and Vienne were attacked by mobs and then by the authorities. Their letter describing it, preserved by Eusebius (Church History 5.1), tells of the aged bishop Pothinus, over ninety, dying in prison, of the deacon Sanctus who answered every question with the words I am a Christian, and of Blandina, a slave woman, whose endurance under torture outlasted her torturers. The first Latin Christian document we have, the Acts of the Scillitan Martyrs, records the trial at Carthage on 17 July 180 of twelve Christians from a small town in North Africa. Asked what they had in their case, their spokesman Speratus answered that it held books and the letters of Paul, a just man.
2. Smyrna and Carthage: the martyrs the church remembered
The Martyrdom of Polycarp is a letter from the church of Smyrna to the church at Philomelium, describing how their bishop was arrested, tried and burned. It is the earliest Christian account of a martyrdom outside the New Testament, and it is usually dated soon after the event, which is placed around 155 or 156, though some historians date the death to the 160s and Candida Moss has argued that the text as we have it was shaped much later. When the proconsul urged the old man to swear by the emperor's fortune and revile Christ, Polycarp replied, in the Ante-Nicene Fathers translation, "Eighty and six years have I served Him, and He never did me any injury: how then can I blaspheme my King and my Saviour?" The letter also says the church gathered his bones and planned to meet each year on the anniversary of his death, the birthday of his martyrdom. That is the beginning of the Christian calendar of saints' days, and it began with a local church remembering its own bishop.
The same letter contains a warning that is easy to miss. It tells of a man named Quintus, a Phrygian, who had pressed himself and others to come forward and give themselves up, and who, when he saw the beasts, lost his nerve and sacrificed. The church writes that for this reason it does not commend those who hand themselves over, since the gospel does not teach this. Clement of Alexandria said the same around 200: those who rush to death are not martyrs but share the guilt of the executioner. Ignatius's longing to be ground by the beasts, in the previous lesson, sits uneasily beside this, and the church never fully resolved the tension between honouring the martyrs' courage and refusing to seek death.
In Carthage on 7 March 203, a group of catechumens, people preparing for baptism, were killed in the arena during games held for the birthday of the young Caesar Geta. Among them were Vibia Perpetua, a well-born woman of about twenty-two with a baby at the breast, and Felicity, a slave, eight months pregnant, who gave birth to a daughter in prison only days before the games. The Passion of Perpetua and Felicity contains a section that claims to be Perpetua's own prison diary, describing her father's anguished pleas that she give up the faith for his sake and her child's, and her visions. If it is genuine, and most specialists accept that it substantially is, it is among the earliest surviving writings by a Christian woman. When her father pleaded with her, she pointed to a water jug and asked whether it could be called by any other name than what it was; when he said no, she answered that neither could she call herself anything other than what she was, a Christian.
The Passion's editor is anonymous. Some have thought him Tertullian, and the text has features some read as sympathetic to the New Prophecy, the movement discussed in the next lesson. What matters here is that the African church read it aloud on the martyrs' day, so widely that Augustine, two centuries later, preached on it more than once (Sermons 280 to 282) and also had to remind readers that it was not canonical scripture (On the Soul and Its Origin 1.10). A slave woman and a noblewoman went into the arena together and were remembered together, and the church in Carthage told the story to every generation.
3. When the empire tried in earnest: Decius, Valerian, Diocletian, and Persia
In late 249 or early 250 the emperor Decius ordered every inhabitant of the empire to sacrifice to the gods, in the presence of officials, and to obtain a certificate proving they had done so. The order was not aimed only at Christians, but it caught them as nothing had before, because for the first time the test was universal and recorded. More than forty of these certificates, called libelli, survive on papyrus from Egypt; each states that the person has always sacrificed to the gods and has now, in the presence of the commissioners, poured a libation, sacrificed and tasted the offering. Fabian, bishop of Rome, was killed in January 250. Origen of Alexandria was tortured and died a few years later of his injuries. Decius himself died in battle in 251 and the campaign ended.
Valerian renewed it in 257 and 258, this time aimed at the church's leaders and its property: clergy were ordered to sacrifice, Christian meetings and cemeteries were banned, and in 258 bishops, presbyters and deacons were to be executed. Sixtus II, bishop of Rome, was beheaded on 6 August 258 while seated in the catacomb where he had been leading worship, and his deacon Lawrence a few days later. Cyprian, bishop of Carthage, was beheaded outside the city on 14 September 258. Valerian was captured by the Persian king Shapur I in 260, and his son Gallienus issued an edict restoring the churches' property. Forty years of relative peace followed, in which the church grew and built openly.
Then came the Great Persecution. On 23 February 303 the new church in Nicomedia, the eastern capital, was demolished, and the next day the emperor Diocletian issued an edict ordering churches destroyed, scriptures surrendered and burned, and Christians stripped of rank and legal protection. Further edicts ordered clergy arrested, then released if they sacrificed, and early in 304 a fourth edict required everyone to sacrifice. Enforcement varied enormously. In the west, Constantius, father of Constantine, did little more than pull down some buildings. In the east, under Galerius and later Maximinus Daia, it was savage and lasted, with interruptions, until 313. Eusebius of Caesarea was an eyewitness and wrote The Martyrs of Palestine about it, and the African writer Lactantius wrote On the Deaths of the Persecutors. In April 311, dying, Galerius issued an edict of toleration, grudgingly allowing Christians to exist and asking them to pray for him. How Constantine changed everything after 312 is the first lesson of the next module.
Persecution did not end for the church when it ended in Rome. Across the eastern border, in the Persian Empire, Christians were a significant minority, and once Rome became Christian they were suspected of loyalty to the enemy. Under Shapur II, from around 340, a long persecution began. Simeon bar Sabbae, bishop of Seleucia-Ctesiphon, the Persian capital, was executed with many of his clergy, and the fifth-century historian Sozomen reported that the names of some sixteen thousand martyrs in Persia were known, besides a multitude whose names were not (Church History 2.14). The Church of the East, whose story the Missions track tells in the lesson of that name, was born and shaped under this pressure. A history of persecution that ends in 313 has looked only at one empire.
4. The lapsed: Cyprian, Novatian and the Donatists
Persecution created a problem the church had never faced at scale. Under Decius thousands of Christians sacrificed, or burned incense, or bribed an official for a certificate without sacrificing. They were called the lapsed, and when the persecution ended many of them wanted to come back. Some confessors, believers who had been imprisoned and survived, were writing letters of peace on their own authority, readmitting the lapsed without any penance at all. Others said those who had denied Christ could never be restored by the church, whatever God might do. Both answers claimed the authority of the martyrs.
Cyprian had become bishop of Carthage only in 248 or 249. When Decius's edict came he went into hiding and governed his church by letter, which some in Carthage and in the Roman clergy held against him; he defended it as obedience to the command to flee and as care for his flock. When he returned he insisted that only the bishops together could decide the question. In 251 he wrote On the Lapsed and On the Unity of the Church, and a council at Carthage that year agreed that the lapsed could be restored after a period of penance, with those who had actually sacrificed treated more strictly than those who had obtained certificates. In On the Unity of the Church he wrote the sentence for which he is best known, in the Ante-Nicene Fathers wording: "He can no longer have God for his Father, who has not the Church for his mother."
At Rome the same question split the church. When Cornelius was chosen bishop in 251 and took a merciful line, a learned presbyter named Novatian was consecrated as a rival bishop by those who held that the church had no power to readmit those who had committed idolatry. Novatian was no heretic in doctrine; he had written an orthodox treatise on the Trinity. His church, whose members called themselves the pure, spread across the empire and lasted for centuries, and the Council of Nicaea in 325 laid down terms for receiving Novatianist clergy back. The dispute was not about what Christians believe but about what the church is: a community of the pure, or a hospital for sinners who repent.
The Great Persecution produced the same quarrel in a harder form in North Africa. Diocletian's first edict demanded the surrender of scriptures, and those who handed them over were called traditores, people who handed over, from which the English word traitor comes. In 311 or 312 a new bishop of Carthage, Caecilian, was consecrated by a bishop, Felix of Aptunga, who was accused of having been a traditor. A council of Numidian bishops declared the consecration invalid and consecrated a rival, Majorinus, who was soon succeeded by Donatus, after whom the movement was named. The Donatists held that a sacrament administered by a bishop who had betrayed Christ was no sacrament, and that the true church was the church of the martyrs, which had not compromised. They rebaptised those who joined them. Appeals to Constantine, a synod at Rome in 313 and a council at Arles in 314 all went against them, and they did not accept the verdict. For a century the Donatist church was the majority church in much of North Africa.
Augustine, as bishop of Hippo from the 390s, gave the answer that became the Western church's position: the holiness of the sacraments depends on Christ, not on the minister, so baptism given by an unworthy priest is still Christ's baptism, and the church on earth is a mixed body of wheat and weeds until the harvest. At the conference of Carthage in 411 the imperial commissioner ruled against the Donatists and the state moved to suppress them. Augustine at first opposed using force and then came to defend it, reading Luke 14:23, compel them to come in, as warrant for imperial pressure to bring schismatics back (Letter 93). Tell that part honestly. A church born in persecution, within a century, was asking the state to coerce dissenters, and the arguments Augustine made would be used for far worse purposes in later centuries. The historian W. H. C. Frend, in The Donatist Church (1952), argued that Donatism was also an expression of rural Numidian and Berber resentment against Roman Carthage; others have thought that reading underplays how theological the dispute was. Both elements were probably present.
5. How widespread was it? Candida Moss and her critics
The traditional picture, shaped by Eusebius and later by medieval collections of martyr stories, is of three centuries of continuous persecution and countless martyrs. Historians have long qualified this. Origen, writing around 248 in Against Celsus 3.8, said that only a few Christians, easily numbered, had died for the faith up to his time, though he wrote just before Decius. Edward Gibbon, in the sixteenth chapter of The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire in 1776, estimated that fewer than two thousand died in the Great Persecution, and he was accused of minimising Christian suffering for anti-Christian reasons. Twentieth-century scholars such as Frend and de Ste. Croix, from very different standpoints, agreed that persecution was intermittent and mostly local before 250.
Candida Moss, a New Testament scholar who has taught at Notre Dame and Birmingham, pressed this further in The Myth of Persecution (2013), following two academic books on early martyrdom. She argued that the period in which emperors actually directed persecution against Christians amounts to fewer than ten years, in the reigns of Decius, Valerian and Diocletian; that many Christians who died were prosecuted under general laws rather than hunted for their faith; that most martyr accounts were edited, expanded or invented later, sometimes much later; and that the story of a church perpetually persecuted became a powerful part of Christian identity, one she believes is misused when modern Christians describe disagreement with them as persecution. Her strongest points are the textual ones. It is true that most martyr acts survive in later forms, that many were embellished, and that only a handful, such as the letter on Lyons and Vienne, the Scillitan acts, Polycarp's Martyrdom and Perpetua's Passion, are generally regarded as early, and even some of those are debated.
Her critics, among them N. Clayton Croy in the Review of Biblical Literature and Ephraim Radner in First Things, and including specialists who accept much of her reading of the sources, answer at several points. They argue that the distinction between being prosecuted and being persecuted does not hold when the offence is refusing to worship the gods and the penalty is death; Trajan's rescript made confessing Christ a capital matter for a century and a half, whether or not the emperor ordered a campaign. They point out that sporadic does not mean slight: a church that could lose its bishop to a mob or a governor's whim at any time lived under real threat even in years when no one died, and the fear shaped its worship, its meeting places and its literature. They note that Christians were also exposed to social and legal disadvantage short of death, loss of property, exile and the mines. And some argue that her concern with modern rhetoric shaped the way she framed ancient evidence, so that the book reads at points as an argument with present-day Christians rather than a history. Moss, for her part, has never denied that Christians were executed for their faith. Her claim concerns scale, the reliability of the sources and the use the story is put to, and she would answer that a critic who points to the reality of martyrdom is answering a claim she did not make.
What can be said as settled? Persecution before 250 was real, local, unpredictable and lethal, and it made being a Christian a legal risk everywhere. Empire-wide persecution came in three waves in the second half of the third century and the first decade of the fourth, and it was severe. Numbers are uncertain, and an honest historian will not give one. Many martyr stories as we have them are embellished, and a church that tells them should be able to say which are early and which are legend. And persecution did not stop in 313; it continued in Persia and has continued in many places since. Hold both truths together: the early church was not hunted every day for three centuries, and it was also never safe.
Notice what the debate over the lapsed shows, whichever side you take on Moss. The hardest pastoral problem the persecutions left was not the dead but the living who had failed. Both Novatian and the Donatists were rigorists who wanted a pure church; Cyprian and Augustine, in different ways, argued for a church that can receive back those who fall. That argument is not over. It returns every time a church decides what to do with a member who has fallen badly and repents.
6. This week: your church's suffering, and its mercy
Add the second page to your church history notebook. Head it Persecution and restoration. Write down whether your congregation or denomination has ever suffered for its faith: imprisonment, violence, loss of land or buildings, exclusion from schools or jobs, or pressure from the state or from another religious group. Note when, where and in what form, as far as you can learn it. If your tradition remembers martyrs, record them as the church remembers them, using the names of those long dead that the church already publicly honours, but no names of living believers.
A safety rule matters here more than anywhere in this track. If your church lives under pressure now, do not write down who is at risk, where you meet, or who has helped. Write in general terms, keep the notebook safe, and if in doubt leave it out. The church at Smyrna wrote down Polycarp's story after he was dead and beyond harm. Follow that example.
Then write a paragraph on how your church treats those who have fallen away and want to return. Does it require a time of repentance, a public confession, a period before taking communion again, or simply a welcome? Where did that practice come from? Compare it with Cyprian's council of 251 and with the Novatianist refusal, and write one sentence on which of them your church's practice is closest to. Finally, read Revelation 2:10 again and write one line on what it would mean for your congregation to be faithful even unto death in its present circumstances.
Key terms
- martysGreek
- A witness, one who testifies to what he has seen. In Acts 1:8 the apostles are witnesses; by Acts 22:20 and Revelation 2:13 the word is used of those who bore witness by being killed. By the second century martyr meant one who died for the faith, and confessor one who suffered and survived.
- libellusLatin
- A little book or certificate. Under Decius in 250 it was the official document proving that a person had sacrificed to the gods. More than forty survive from Egypt. Christians who obtained one without sacrificing were called libellatici, and the church had to decide how to treat them.
- traditorLatin
- One who handed over, used of Christians who surrendered scriptures or church property to the authorities under Diocletian's edict of 303. The charge that a bishop had been a traditor began the Donatist schism in North Africa, and the word gave English the word traitor.
Knowledge check
What was the central disagreement in both the Novatian schism at Rome and the Donatist schism in North Africa?