Lesson 5 · 26 min

Africa and the Early Church

Some of the most important thinking, praying and dying of the early church happened in Africa: in Alexandria and the Egyptian desert, in Carthage and Hippo, in Nubia and Ethiopia. This lesson tells who these Christians were, why the Latin church of North Africa largely vanished while the Coptic and Ethiopian churches endured, and how far Thomas Oden's claim that Africa shaped the Christian mind holds up against its critics.

So he started out, and on his way he met an Ethiopian eunuch, a court official in charge of the entire treasury of Candace, queen of the Ethiopians. He had gone to Jerusalem to worship,

Acts 8:27 · BSB

Before you read

Work these first, with the passage open and the lesson unread. Write your answers down. The exposition below is what you check them against, not what you copy them from.

  1. Observe

    Read Acts 8:26-39. Write down everything the text tells you about the Ethiopian official: his position, his reason for travelling, what he was doing in his chariot, what he asked, and what he did at the end of the story.

  2. Notice

    Read Acts 2:10, Acts 11:20, Acts 13:1, Acts 18:24 and Mark 15:21. List every African person or place named, and write down what each one did or where each one appears in the story of the church.

  3. Hear it then

    Using a Bible atlas or the maps in STEP Bible, find where the Ethiopia of Acts 8 was, and compare it with Psalm 68:31 and Jeremiah 38:7. What did Ethiopia or Cush mean to a reader of the Greek and Hebrew scriptures, and why might Luke have wanted this story told where it is in Acts?

  4. Weigh the words

    On Blue Letter Bible or STEP Bible, look up the Greek word Aithiops at Acts 8:27 and the Hebrew word Kush at Psalm 68:31 and Zephaniah 3:10. Write down what each word means and which region it describes, and notice whether either word is a name for the whole continent.

  5. Why it matters

    Write down where you have usually imagined the early church's great teachers living, and what they looked like. Then write one sentence on where that picture came from: books, pictures, films, sermons. Keep the page; this lesson will test it.

1. The Nile and the coast: two African churches

When people in Lagos, Nairobi or Kinshasa are told that Christianity is a white man's religion, the early church is the first answer. Christianity was in Africa before it was in most of Europe. The Ethiopian official of Acts 8 was baptised within a few years of the resurrection, before Paul's first letter was written. By the year 200 there were large and learned churches in Egypt and in the Roman province called Africa, roughly modern Tunisia and eastern Algeria, and by the fourth century Christianity was the faith of a kingdom in the Ethiopian highlands. The Missions track has told how the gospel reached Aksum through Frumentius, in the lesson How the Early Church Grew, and how it spread through ordinary believers. This lesson tells what the African churches did with the faith once it had arrived.

There were really two early African Christianities, and it helps to keep them apart. The first was the church of the Nile: Alexandria, the great Greek-speaking city at the river's mouth, and behind it the Coptic-speaking towns and villages of Egypt, the monasteries of the desert, and further south Nubia and, by a different road, Ethiopia. The second was the church of the coast west of Egypt: Carthage and the cities of the Roman province of Africa and of Numidia, Latin-speaking in its cities, Punic- and Berber-speaking in its countryside. These two churches had different languages, different traditions and different fates. Both were African.

Christian memory says the church of Alexandria was founded by Mark. Eusebius reports the tradition (Church History 2.16), and the Coptic Orthodox Church today calls its patriarch the Pope of Alexandria and successor of Saint Mark. Historians cannot prove or disprove it; what is clear is that by the late second century Alexandria had a large church and a famous school for teaching the faith. The early history of the Carthaginian church is darker, but by 180 it had martyrs, by 197 it had Tertullian, and by the middle of the third century councils of Carthage could gather eighty or more bishops from across the province.

2. Alexandria and the desert

Alexandria was the intellectual capital of the Greek world, home of the great library and of the Jewish scholar Philo, and the city where the Hebrew scriptures had been translated into Greek. Its Christians founded a school of instruction, and its teachers set out to show that the faith could meet the best learning of the age on its own ground. Pantaenus, the first known teacher, was said by Eusebius to have travelled as far as India (Church History 5.10). Clement of Alexandria, who taught there around 190 to 202, wrote an Exhortation to the Greeks, a guide to the Christian life called The Instructor, and the Miscellanies, arguing that philosophy had prepared the Greeks for Christ as the law had prepared the Jews.

Origen, born around 185 to a Christian family in Alexandria, was the greatest scholar of the early church. His father Leonides was martyred in 202, and the teenage Origen, according to Eusebius, wanted to follow him and was prevented only because his mother hid his clothes. He became head of the school as a young man, lived with fierce austerity, and wrote more than any Christian before him. His Hexapla set out the Old Testament in six columns, Hebrew, a Greek transliteration and four Greek translations, so that readers could compare them, which made him the founder of Christian textual scholarship. He wrote commentaries and homilies on most of the Bible, a defence of the faith called Against Celsus, and On First Principles, the first attempt at a connected account of Christian doctrine. He moved to Caesarea in Palestine around 231 after a conflict with his bishop, and was tortured in the persecution of Decius; he died a few years later. Some of his speculations, about the pre-existence of souls and the final restoration of all things, were condemned long after his death, in the sixth century, and the church has argued about him ever since. Nobody argues about his influence.

Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria from 328 to 373, will dominate the next module, where he defends the full divinity of Christ through five exiles. Two things belong here. His thirty-ninth Festal Letter, the subject of the last lesson, gave the first list of the twenty-seven New Testament books. And his Life of Antony, written around 357, introduced the desert monks of Egypt to the whole Christian world. Augustine records in his Confessions (8.6) that hearing the story of Antony was one of the things that brought him to the crisis of his conversion in a garden in Milan. An Egyptian peasant, told by an Alexandrian bishop, helped convert the most influential theologian of the Latin West.

Antony, born around 251 to a Christian farming family in Middle Egypt, heard the Gospel read in church, go, sell your possessions and give to the poor, and did it. He went into the desert to pray and fight temptation, and by the time he died, said to be aged about a hundred and five, in 356, thousands had followed him. Pachomius, a former soldier, founded around 320 at Tabennisi in Upper Egypt the first communities of monks living together under a rule, with shared work, prayer and meals. Women went into the desert too. The sayings of the desert mothers, Amma Syncletica, Amma Sarah and Amma Theodora, are preserved alongside those of the fathers in the collection known as the Sayings of the Desert Fathers, and they are some of the shrewdest spiritual counsel the church possesses. Monasticism as a movement is the first lesson of Module 3, and the Missions track tells how monks carried the gospel. For now notice its birthplace: the Christian monastic life, which shaped the church of every continent, began in the Egyptian desert, among Coptic-speaking farmers.

3. Carthage and Hippo

Tertullian, born in Carthage around 155 and active until about 220, was the first great Christian writer in Latin. He was a convert, trained in rhetoric and perhaps in law, and he wrote with a sharpness nobody in the early church matched. He defended the faith to the Roman authorities in his Apology of 197, attacked Marcion in five books, wrote the first Christian treatise on baptism, and gave Latin theology much of its vocabulary: in his work Against Praxeas, around 213, he is the first writer known to use the Latin word trinitas of God, and he spoke of one substance in three persons, words the whole Western church would later use. He joined the New Prophecy in later life, as Lesson 3 told. His most famous line is that the blood of Christians is seed.

Cyprian, bishop of Carthage from about 248 until his execution in 258, appeared in Lesson 2 at the heart of the dispute over the lapsed. He was a wealthy convert who became one of the great pastors of the early church, governing a church under persecution and through a plague, organising care for the sick of every faith, and gathering councils of African bishops to decide hard questions together. His treatise On the Unity of the Church shaped every later Western argument about what the church is. When he was sentenced to death in 258 the record says his people laid cloths on the ground to catch his blood, and he gave the executioner a gift of gold.

Augustine was born on 13 November 354 at Thagaste, in Numidia, modern Souk Ahras in Algeria, to a pagan father and a Christian mother, Monica, whose name many think is Berber. He studied at Carthage, spent nine years as a follower of the Manichees, a dualist religion from Persia, taught rhetoric at Carthage, Rome and Milan, and was converted in Milan in 386 and baptised by its bishop, Ambrose, at Easter 387. He returned to Africa, was ordained presbyter at Hippo Regius, modern Annaba, in 391, and became its bishop around 395 or 396. From that small port town he wrote the Confessions, around 397 to 400, The City of God, from 413 to 426, On the Trinity, and hundreds of sermons and letters, against the Manichees, the Donatists and the Pelagians, who taught that human beings could keep God's commands without his transforming grace. He died on 28 August 430 while the Vandals besieged Hippo.

It is hard to overstate Augustine's reach. Medieval Catholic theology, including Aquinas, is built on him. Luther was an Augustinian friar, and Calvin quotes Augustine more than any other writer. Every Western church, Catholic and Protestant, has argued about grace, sin, predestination and the church in categories Augustine set. The Eastern churches have been more reserved about him, and some Orthodox theologians have argued that Western Christianity leaned too heavily on one African bishop's reading of Romans. Either way, a great deal of what the world calls Western Christianity was first worked out by an African in an African town.

4. Nubia and Ethiopia, and the church that vanished

South of Egypt, along the Nile, the kingdoms of Nubia became Christian in the sixth century. The historian John of Ephesus describes a mission sent around 543 to the kingdom of Nobadia, and the three Nubian kingdoms, Nobadia, Makuria and Alodia, were Christian for nearly a thousand years. In the 1960s Polish archaeologists led by Kazimierz Michalowski uncovered the cathedral at Faras, its walls covered with paintings of saints, bishops and Nubian royalty, now preserved in Warsaw and Khartoum. Christian Nubia declined from the fourteenth century under pressure from Egypt and the migration of Arab tribes, and by around 1500 the last Christian kingdom had gone. For nearly a thousand years the gospel the Ethiopian official carried home was confessed in the land he came from.

In the Ethiopian highlands the church that Frumentius founded in the fourth century took deep root. Late in the fifth century a group of monks remembered as the Nine Saints, traditionally from the Roman east, strengthened the monastic life and the translation of scripture and liturgy into Ge'ez, the language of Aksum. The Garima Gospels, kept for centuries at a monastery in the Tigray region, have been dated by radiocarbon tests to a range that places them among the oldest surviving illustrated Gospel books in the world. The Ethiopian church kept the widest canon of any church, as the last lesson told, kept the Sabbath alongside the Lord's day, as the next lesson notes, and for sixteen centuries received its chief bishop from the Coptic patriarch in Alexandria, until it gained its own patriarch in 1959. It has never been a colonial church. It is one of the oldest national churches on earth.

The Latin church of North Africa had a different fate. The Vandals, Arian Christians from across the Mediterranean, crossed into Africa in 429 and took Carthage in 439, and persecuted the catholic bishops for decades. The Byzantine emperor Justinian reconquered the region in 533 and 534. Then the Arab armies came, and Carthage fell in 698. Christianity did not disappear at once; it shrank slowly over centuries, under taxation and social pressure and conversion. In 1076 Pope Gregory VII wrote that he could not find the three bishops in Africa needed to consecrate a new one. By the twelfth century the church of Tertullian, Cyprian and Augustine was effectively gone, while the Coptic church in Egypt and the church in Ethiopia survived to the present.

Why the difference? Historians have offered several answers, and they are best held together rather than set against each other. One, argued by W. H. C. Frend and others, is language: the Coptic and Ethiopian churches worshipped and read scripture in the language of the people, while the North African church was Latin in its cities and seems never to have translated the Bible into Punic or Berber. Augustine himself had to search for Punic-speaking clergy for country parishes, and his letters show the difficulty. Another is division: the Donatist schism had split the African church for a century, and the Vandal persecution and Byzantine rule left it weakened and tied to foreign powers. A third points to geography and politics: the coast lay in the path of every army, while Ethiopia's mountains and Egypt's sheer numbers of Christians gave those churches time. Critics of the language thesis note that Christianity in Egypt also declined steeply under Muslim rule, that Latin was more widely spoken in Roman Africa than the thesis assumes, and that we know too little about rural African Christianity to be sure what language it prayed in. What can be said is that churches which made the faith their own, in their own tongue, proved harder to uproot, and that is a lesson every African church today has a stake in.

5. Thomas Oden and his critics

Thomas Oden, an American Methodist theologian who had turned from liberal Protestantism to the study of the church fathers, argued in How Africa Shaped the Christian Mind (2007) that the early African church was not a branch of European Christianity but one of its roots. He named a series of areas in which he believed African Christians had led the way, among them the idea of the university in the schools of Alexandria, the methods of biblical interpretation, the formation of core doctrine, the practice of councils deciding together, and monasticism, and he called the early African church the seedbed of Western Christianity. He also argued that intellectual movement often ran from south to north, from Africa into Europe, rather than the other way round, and he urged African scholars to recover these sources as their own. He followed it with The African Memory of Mark (2011), defending the African tradition that Mark founded the church of Alexandria, and he helped found a centre and a network of scholars across Africa to study early African Christianity.

Oden's case at its strongest runs like this. Geography is not a matter of opinion: Alexandria, Carthage and Hippo are in Africa, and the Romans themselves called the province Africa. For centuries Western textbooks treated Origen, Athanasius and Augustine as honorary Europeans and left African students with the impression that their continent had no Christian past before the missionaries. That impression is false and has done real harm. Many of these writers were natives of Africa, some, like Augustine and Tertullian, from families that had lived there for generations, and the Coptic, Nubian and Ethiopian churches were African by any definition. African theologians had been making related arguments before Oden. The Ghanaian theologian Kwame Bediako, in Theology and Identity (1992), read the second-century fathers alongside modern African theologians and argued that both were working out how to be fully Christian and fully at home in their own culture.

The critics, who include scholars sympathetic to Oden's purpose, make several points. They argue that calling Alexandrian and Carthaginian writers African in a modern sense is anachronistic: Origen and Athanasius wrote in Greek, Tertullian and Augustine in Latin, and they thought of themselves as belonging to the Mediterranean world of the Roman Empire, not to a continent. They note that much of what Oden credits to Africa was shared across a single Greek and Roman world in which ideas moved in every direction, so that singling out one shore of the Mediterranean as the source can overstate the case. Some warn that the argument can slide into claims Oden himself did not make, for example that these writers were black in the modern racial sense, which the sources do not tell us, and that replacing a European myth with an African one does not help students understand the past. And some think the book's tone is closer to advocacy than to history in places, pressing claims, about the direction of influence for example, further than the evidence goes.

What should a student hold? It is settled that Africa was one of the heartlands of early Christianity, that several of its most important teachers were born, worked and died in Africa, that Christian monasticism began in Egypt, and that the churches of Egypt and Ethiopia have kept the faith without a break for more than fifteen hundred years. It is fair to say that Western histories long ignored or minimised this. It is also fair to say that these ancient Christians did not think in terms of modern continents or modern races, and that their world was a Mediterranean one in which Africa, Asia and Europe met. A student can honour Augustine as an African and also read him as he read himself, a Roman provincial and a citizen of the city of God. Both are true, and students will weigh them differently.

One more caution. The point of recovering this history is not to win an argument about whose continent did more. It is to let African Christians see that the faith was never foreign to them, and to let Christians everywhere see that the church has always been a body of many peoples. The Ethiopian official of Acts 8 did not become a Christian because the gospel had become European. It reached him on a desert road, through an open scroll of Isaiah, before there was a church in Rome.

6. This week: the African roots of your church

Add page five to your church history notebook and head it Our roots through Africa. Every Christian tradition passes through Africa somewhere. If your church is Coptic, Ethiopian or Eritrean Orthodox, its line runs directly back through Alexandria. If it is Catholic, Anglican, Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist, Baptist or Pentecostal, it inherited the New Testament list Athanasius first wrote, the doctrine of grace and the church that Augustine framed, the vocabulary of the Trinity that Tertullian coined, and the monastic and ascetic traditions that began in Egypt. Write down which of these lines your own church most clearly carries, and in what form you meet it: a hymn, a creed, a practice, a book.

Then, if you live in Africa or your church has African roots, write down what you know about how the faith reached your own people in the modern period, and whether anyone in your church knows about the ancient African church at all. Ask a leader in your church, by role, whether they were taught anything about Augustine, Athanasius or the Ethiopian church when they were trained. If you live elsewhere, write one sentence on what difference it makes to your church's picture of itself to know that some of its most important teachers were African.

Finally, go back to the page you wrote in the inquiry about where you imagined the early church's teachers living. Write two sentences on what you would change about that picture now, and where you would send someone who wanted to read these teachers for free. The Christian Classics Ethereal Library at ccel.org and the Fathers section of New Advent carry the Ante-Nicene and Nicene Fathers translations of Tertullian, Cyprian, Origen, Athanasius and Augustine at no cost.

Key terms

AithiopsGreek
An Ethiopian, in Greek usage a person from the lands south of Egypt. The Ethiopia of Acts 8:27 is the kingdom of Meroe in modern Sudan, ruled by queens titled Kandake, not the later kingdom of Aksum from which modern Ethiopia descends. In the Old Testament the same region is Cush.
CoptEnglish
An Egyptian Christian, from the Arabic qibt, itself from the Greek word for Egyptian. The Coptic Orthodox Church traces its line to Mark and Alexandria, and Coptic, the last stage of the ancient Egyptian language, was the language of the desert monks and of the early Egyptian Bible translations.
trinitasLatin
Trinity. First used of God in Latin, as far as surviving texts show, by Tertullian of Carthage in his work Against Praxeas around 213, where he also spoke of one substance and three persons. The Greek trias appears a little earlier in Theophilus of Antioch.
Push on this with the AI Theology Tutor. It already knows what this lesson argued.

Knowledge check

According to the lesson, which explanation is offered for why the Coptic and Ethiopian churches survived while the Latin church of North Africa largely vanished?